Anne lowered her eyes.

“Your Grace is kind.”

“I’m not kind,” said the Duke quietly. “I’m a man who has not read his own ledgers in 3 years. Leave your trunk where it is, Mrs. Barrington.”

He did not send for the magistrate that day. He sent instead, for 10:00 on Saturday morning, for the whole household. Tenants gathered for the spring rent audit, grooms and footmen, Mrs. Fairfax with her keys, Lady Jane in lilac silk, and Mr. Carlyle with his ledgers beneath his arm and an expression of faint, patient contempt. Anne he seated in the great carved chair at his right hand, the first chair in that hall that had ever been offered her.

“Mr. Carlyle,” said the Duke, “for 3 years you have told me that my harvests failed, and on Monday I am to sell Hartley Wood to cover the loss. Before I sign, my nephew will read us what my barns held.”

Ambrose stepped forward with his copybook. His voice cracked on the first word, and the hall, which had expected a child’s recitation, grew very still. Then he found his place as he had been taught to find it, with a finger beneath the line, and read steadily: the acres measured, the sacks counted, the sums carried and ruled. Peregrine held the tally sticks aloft like a standard. Somewhere among the tenants, old Joss the carter began very quietly to laugh.

“Scribbles.”

Mr. Carlyle’s smile had gone.

“Your Grace, you cannot mean to credit the scrawl of children drilled by a widow with a grievance.”

“Mr. Gedge of Catterby is in the passage,” said the Duke. “He has brought his receipts. He is an honest man, I am told, and a very frightened one.”

The miller came in with his hat crushed in both hands. He laid three signed papers on the table, and the steward’s name stood on each of them. Mr. Carlyle looked at them, and his face emptied by degrees.

“You will leave the watch chain on the table, Mr. Carlyle,” said the Duke. “It was bought with my sacks. Mr. Sherborne here will recover every pound from whatever you own, and the magistrate will attend to the rest. You may go.”

Two footmen escorted him out, and the hall let out its breath. Lady Jane had half risen.

“Ambrose, the woman has plainly turned the children.”

“You remarked upon Mrs. Barrington’s cuffs at my table,” said the Duke without raising his voice. “You ordered her a room without a fire, and you counted her mended cuffs while a thief counted my sacks. You will beg her pardon now before every servant who heard you, or you will remove to the dower house today.”

The silence stretched. Lady Jane’s lips moved.

“I beg your pardon, Mrs. Barrington,” she said, each syllable a coin counted out.

“It is given, my lady,” said Anne, and nothing in her voice asked for more.

“Hartley Wood will stand,” said the Duke to the tenants now, and a murmur went through them like wind through barley. “The estate is not ruined. It has been robbed, and the robbery has been ended by a boy of 12 and a surveyor’s widow. Mrs. Barrington, I cannot make you steward. The county would never forgive me. I may, however, create an office. From today, you are auditor of the Calverley estate at 300 pounds a year with the keys to every book in this house. My nephews will be your clerks, and I should be obliged if you would remain their governess in whatever fashion pleases you.”

Anne could not speak. Beside the hearth, Kitty Gresham, who had slipped in among the maids, had her apron pressed to her mouth.

“Miss Gresham,” said the Duke, who noticed everything, “you will attend Mrs. Barrington at a lady’s maid’s wage, and Mrs. Fairfax will see that every fire in the north passage is lit before nightfall.”

A year to the day, the Duke stood once more in the schoolroom doorway, a ring in his pocket, and for the second time in his life, no words ready.

“I once could not decide whom to thank,” he said. “I have since resolved the difficulty. I mean to thank you every day, Anne, for the rest of my life.”

She rose, set down her pen, and gave him her hand.