“Oh,” said May. “I was not talking. That is, I was talking but only to the curtains. I talk to curtains. Everyone in my family does. It is hereditary, like freckles.”

The woman’s smile did not move an inch.

“How charming. I am Louisa Fenwick, Charles’s sister.”

She stepped into the room as though it belonged to her and closed the door softly behind her.

“And you must be May, little May Dawson. Do you know, I feel as if I have known you for years.”

“Have you?” May said. “How strange. I have never heard of you at all.”

That was the truth, and May watched it land. For a single moment, something flickered behind Louisa’s eyes before the smile settled back into place.

“No, I don’t suppose you would have.”

Louisa drifted toward the mantel and studied the little china shepherdess there as though she were deciding whether to buy it.

“Henry was always so private about his Oxford friends, but he talked about you constantly. May this, May that. How you fell from the orchard wall and he carried you home on his back and you complained the entire way that he was walking too slowly.”

May’s breath caught. That was true, every word of it. She had complained.

He had laughed at her the whole way, and she had never forgotten it. And it seemed Henry had not either. For one foolish, glowing heartbeat, May let herself believe that he had carried that memory with him all the way to Oxford because it meant to him what it meant to her.

“He was so fond of you,” Louisa went on, turning back with a small sigh. “The way a man is fond of a favorite sister. He used to say he would marry any woman in England except you because he could never in his life think of you that way.”

The glow went out like a candle. May had a sudden, very vivid picture of herself crossing the room, picking up the vase of white roses from the side table, and pouring every drop of water over Louisa Fenwick’s perfect dark curls. She could see it so clearly.

Louisa would shriek, the roses would stick out of her hair like a hat, and May would say something devastating and sweep out of the room like a queen. She blinked. Louisa was still dry and still smiling.

“Well, he has married me now, so he must have thought about it at least once. Perhaps on a Tuesday.”

“Perhaps.”

Louisa’s gaze dropped to the ring on May’s finger, then lifted again, slow and knowing.

“Though I couldn’t help overhearing you just now, Your Grace. Nothing but a rake, I think it was. You needn’t worry. I shan’t repeat it. We all knew what Henry was at Oxford. Some of us knew him better than others, of course.”

She let that sit in the air between them like perfume. May’s cheeks burned. She wanted very badly to ask what that meant, and she wanted even more badly not to know. Instead, she lifted her chin.

“My father built this house, Miss Fenwick. He builds very good walls. You would be amazed what they keep out.”

For the first time, Louisa laughed, and it was not a kind sound.

“Oh, I do like you. Henry said you were funny.”

She moved toward the door.

“But do be careful, darling. You’ve known him all your life, I know. Only, a man can tell a sister one story, and a woman quite another. And I wonder which Henry you think you married.”