May opened her mouth to answer, and found she had nothing to say, because she was thinking of the letters from Oxford, so long and so cheerful, and of how not one of them had ever mentioned a Louisa. She was thinking of the Widow Pell, and the actress whose name she had forgotten on purpose, and of the boy who had carried her home on his back. She had believed she knew every corner of Henry’s heart. Now, she wondered whether she had only ever been shown the rooms he kept tidy for guests. The door opened before Louisa reached it.

“May, there you are. I have been looking everywhere.”

Henry stopped dead on the threshold. His eyes went from Louisa, standing so close to him, to May on the window seat with her hands knotted in her lap. Whatever he saw on his wife’s face drained the color from his own.

“Henry,” Louisa said warmly. “We were just getting acquainted. Your wife and I have so much to talk about.”

And May looked up at Henry as though she was seeing him for the very first time. Henry did not look at Louisa again. He crossed the room to May and held out his arm as though there were no one else there at all.

“Miss Fenwick,” he said with a short, correct bow. “You will forgive us. My wife is expected at the breakfast.”

‘Miss Fenwick.’ Not Louisa. May noticed it the way she noticed everything all at once and far too much.

“Of course, Your Grace,” Louisa said sweetly. “I wouldn’t dream of keeping her.”

Henry did not answer. He simply waited until May’s hand was on his arm, then led her out of the room and closed the door behind them without a backward glance. The corridor was quiet. Henry walked quickly, his jaw set so hard May could see a muscle jumping in his cheek.

He did not say a word and May, who could never in her life bear a silence, began to fill it in her head. Was he angry with her? Perhaps he was angry because she had run off from her own wedding breakfast, which was fair really after running off from her own wedding. Or was he angry with Louisa?

But a man was only that cold to a woman when he had once been something else to her, surely. May had read enough novels to know that. In her mind she saw Henry at Oxford, younger and laughing, bending close to Louisa Fenwick in some candlelit room. And she shook the picture away so fast she nearly walked into a potted palm.

“She has lovely hair,” May heard herself say. “Miss Fenwick, very shiny, like a beetle.”

Henry stopped walking.

“Did she say something to you?”

“No. Nothing. Nothing at all. We discussed the curtains.”

“The curtains?”

“They are very good curtains, Henry. My father chose them himself.”

He looked at her for a long moment and May knew he did not believe a word of it. That made two lies she had told him today and they had not even cut the cake yet.

“Stay away from her, May,” he said quietly.

Then he turned and walked on and May was left more confused than ever. Was he protecting her or hiding something from her? She could not tell, and Henry had never once in her life been a man she could not read. The dining room erupted into applause the moment they appeared. Her father rose to give a toast.

Charles Fenwick gave a far longer one, and May laughed in all the right places without hearing a single word. Henry pulled out her chair for her. When she sat, he brushed a loose curl back from her cheek so gently that her heart turned over. Then she remembered. ‘The way a man is fond of a favorite sister.’ So, that was what this was, May thought, watching him pour her a glass of water before she had even asked.

Every kindness, every gentle touch, every time he had ever looked after her. She had spent years treasuring them. And perhaps they had only ever been the kindness of a brother. She smiled at her husband and felt her heart crack quietly down the middle.

Back in the little sitting room, Louisa Fenwick stood alone by the window where May had sat. The noise of the breakfast drifted faintly down the corridor, and she listened to it for a while, smiling at nothing. Then she opened her reticule and took out a letter.

The paper was soft and worn, folded and unfolded so many times the creases had nearly worn through. The handwriting on it was Henry’s. Louisa read it once more, slowly, and her smile grew.


PART 3 — The Letter That Was Always Hers – She Ran From Her Own Wedding After One Thought Changed Her Mind

PART 3 — The Letter That Was Always Hers – She Ran From Her Own Wedding After One Thought Changed Her Mind