He stopped. His hands had found the button and he held it, but he did not roll it.

“The snow came on harder. I got lost. I remember falling near the old quarry and Thomas was there. I remember Thomas. I remember him putting his coat around me and doing up the buttons and his hands shaking. And then nothing. Snow and a light and a voice.”

“What did the voice say?” said Hester.

Her own voice sounded strange to her.

“I don’t know. I’ve heard it in my dreams for 17 years, and I never catch the words. A small voice. I think it was a child’s, but that’s impossible.”

He turned the button over.

“When I woke up, I was at home in my bed with a fever that lasted 6 weeks, and Thomas was dead. They found him beside me in his shirt, frozen. He had given me his coat, you see. He came out into the snow after me because I was a fool, and he gave me his coat, and he died of it.”

He said it flatly, the way a man recites a lesson he has learned by heart.

“My father said it to me in the yard that night before I knew anything. ‘He went out after you.’ He never said another word about it for the rest of his life. He never spoke Thomas’s name to me again.”

“And you’ve never worn a coat since,” said Hester.

“I don’t deserve to be warm,” said Gideon. “He was cold because of me. I don’t see why I should be anything else.”

He tried to smile and did not manage it.

“There, now you know what you’d be marrying. You see why I don’t expect you to say yes on the 1st of May.”

Hester did not answer at once. She was looking at the lantern and she was not seeing it. She was seeing another lantern on another night a long time ago.

She had been 8 years old. Her mother had been buried in Kennesley Churchyard on the Thursday of that week in the snow. And on the Saturday night, Hester had run away from the silent house and walked four miles to the hill farm at Huntington on the far side of the ridge because Owen Vaughn was there for the lambing, and Owen was the only person left in the world who was kind to her. And Owen had not sent her home. He had wrapped her in a sack and taken her up the ridge with him at first light after the worst of the storm to look for buried sheep.

“Look for the breath, Hessie.” She remembered the white and the cold and the quarry edge and a little hole in the snow bigger than her thumb with a yellow rim. She remembered kneeling and scrabbling at it with her hands and shouting something, and she remembered two boys. One of them had been very still. The other had been wearing a blue coat.

She had been told afterwards that they were two lads from over the hill and that the living one had been taken home. She had sometimes wondered as she grew older whether they had been the Duke’s sons. And she had put the wondering away the way one puts away a thing that hurts because that week was the week of her mother’s death and she did not like to go near it. And because whenever she asked Owen, he said only, “Some things aren’t ours to tell, Hessie.” She sat on the straw beside Gideon in the lower fold, and she thought in plain words so that there could be no mistake.

“I was the child on the hill. Owen and I found him. That is why the old Duke chose me.” She opened her mouth to tell him and then she shut it again because she knew exactly what he would do. He would look at her the way he had looked at the coat and he would marry her on the 1st of May out of debt and gratitude and duty, the way he had proposed to her, like a man paying a bill. And Hester Kennesley had been useful to people all her life. She had been useful to her father and useful to her stepmother and useful to Celia.