He laid one sheet on top of the others and held the candle a little closer.
“This is the best of them. Look at it.”
It was the sea campion. Branwin had drawn it last June, kneeling on the short turf at the top of the cliff, with the wind trying to take the paper. She had sat up half the night afterwards trying to get the white of the petals right against the white of the page. She looked down at her own drawing on the duke’s table by the duke’s candle, with the duke’s hand resting beside it. She could not say a word.
“She signs herself Carrow,” he said. “She is in London this spring, as it happens. We leave our letters at a bookseller’s. I have never dared to wait for her in the shop. I told myself I would thank her properly when the book is finished.”
He was quiet a moment.
“I have not shown this to anyone. My father would not have it in the house when my mother was alive. He thought it a foolish thing for a duchess to do, and a worse thing for her son to care about.”
He touched the edge of one of the old yellow pages, and Branwin saw that it was scorched brown along one side.
“The night after her funeral, he put her drawings on the fire. I was 19. I pulled out what I could and took them and left the house. I stayed abroad four years. When I did come back, it was because they wrote to me that he was dying. I rode three days without stopping. He died the night before I reached him.”
He stopped. He did not look at her. He looked at the scorched page under his hand, and Branwin watched him try to go on and fail and try again.
“They gave me his papers,” he said at last. “Your father’s promise was on the top of them. He had written across the corner of it, ‘See this honored, Theo. It is the one debt I never paid.’ That was all he left me. Not a word about the rest. Only that.”
He let out a long breath.
“So I am finishing my mother’s book under my own plain name because she would have wanted it. And I am keeping my father’s promise because he asked me to. And I do not know how to stop being angry with him for making me choose between them, even now when they are both in the ground.”
Branwin took his hand. She did it without thinking, as she would have reached for anybody in pain. It was the hand with the blackthorn scratch across the back of it, healing now. His breath caught. Then his fingers turned and closed round hers.
They stood there together over his mother’s drawings and her own without a word. Somewhere in the house, a clock struck 10. The candles leaned in the draft from the window. It was the first time she had touched him without gloves, and she thought she would remember the feel of his hand for the rest of her life.
“You need not choose,” she said at last, very low. “I do not think your mother would have wanted you to. Finish her book, and let your father’s promise be whatever it turns out to be. It need not be a debt.”
He looked down at her then, and she thought for one wild moment that he was going to say something that would change everything. But Benedicta’s voice came along the passage, calling sleepily for her, and he let her hand go and stepped back. And the moment went out of the room like a candle in the wind. The letter was found three days later.
The duke had kept the rest of the ballroom primroses, the ones he had not sent to her. When they grew too tall for the room, he told the gardener to plant them out in the garden behind the house, along the foot of the wall where the ivy grew. The gardener lifted them out of the moss one by one. At the bottom of the moss in the third window seat, folded and damp and stained green at one corner, he found a sealed letter. It was addressed to the late Duke of Barntow in a hand that nobody in that house had ever seen.
The duke came to Mount Street at 10:00 the next morning, which was far too early for a call. Benedicta was still upstairs in her wrapper. Branwin received him alone in the little front parlor, and she knew what he was carrying before he had taken it from his coat. He held it out to her. The seal was broken.
The paper was stained and wrinkled from the damp, but the words were all there in her father’s strong, square hand.
“You came that afternoon to give me this,” he said.
“Yes.”
“Your father released mine from the promise years ago. He wrote it, and he never sent it.”
He was looking at her face as if he could read the answer there before she said it.
“You came to set yourself free, and then you took off your cloak and did my flowers instead.”
“I meant to give it to you before I left,” she said. “I lost it in the moss, and afterwards—”
She stopped.
“Afterwards, I found I was in no hurry to look for it.”
He was silent. He turned to the window and stood with his back to her, looking out at the plane trees in the square, which had the first faint green on them now.
“You are free,” he said without turning round. “You always were. Your father saw to that, and he was right. I will not hold you to anything, Miss Vancerstone. Not the promise, not the month, not anything. Whatever you choose, you choose for yourself.”