A murmur arose among the crowd. Some nodded, while others shook their heads. Mrs. Bunce placed her hands firmly on her hips.
“I burned my hand back in November,” she declared, holding it up so that everyone could see it clearly. “Do any of you see a single mark?”
“I certainly do not. For forty years my husband has treated his burns with butter and a prayer, yet his hands remain as hard as the bark of an oak tree. This girl healed me in just one morning.”
“And straightened my grandfather’s leg during a blizzard,” shouted the boy from High Scar.
“And she removed my tooth without causing me almost any pain,” said another.
“It hurt like hell,” said the blacksmith.
There was a laugh. The clergyman banged his gavel again.
“Well, well!”
He looked at Imogen.
“Dr. Fairbrass, I think the miller’s question is a good one. Are you going to stay?”
Imogen stood up, opened her mouth to answer, but before she could say a word there was a sound from down the hall. Boots on the wooden floor, long, slow steps. The whole school turned. The Duke of Ranfold was walking down the central aisle, between the benches, towards the minister’s table. People parted as he passed, like water parting around a stone.
No one breathed. In all the history of the village no one had ever heard the Duke say more than two words in a row in public. He reached the table, turned, looked out at the village. Imogen saw the way he clutched his hat, saw his neck stiffen, saw the flush rise to his ears. The silence went on for a long, long time.
Someone coughed. The miller shifted uncomfortably on the bench. Imogen looked him in the eye from her place and said nothing. She simply waited with her hands clasped together without haste. He saw her waiting and began to speak.
“I do not speak.”
The words came out slowly one at a time, like stones someone pulls out of a river.
“You know, they say it’s pride.” He paused, swallowed.
“It’s not pride, it’s this.”
He touched his throat.
“Words have got stuck in my mouth since I was a child. It makes me feel ashamed. That’s why I don’t talk.”
The school was so quiet you could hear the stove crackling.
“The doctor waited for me. No one had ever waited for me.”
He took a deep breath.
“She waited for you too, six empty chairs, a whole week, and she did not leave.”
He looked at the miller, not with anger, but with a calm determination.
“She is leaving, but only because she chooses to, not because we slam the door in her face. Just like in London.”
Imogen felt every single word in her own chest; every hitch, every silence, and every time he swallowed and started again caused her pain. Seeing him so exposed in front of everyone, like a man taking off his coat in the middle of the snow, she realized that she had never felt so much pride for anyone, neither for her own father nor for herself. She never once took her eyes off him, not even for a moment, and every time he searched for her with his gaze, he would always find her waiting there. He turned to the minister.