Lucy flinched, the color draining from her cheeks, but she held her tongue and lowered her head. The cruelty of the words made Emily’s chest seize, but her face remained carved of cold marble. She peeled her glove from her fingers, laying it flat upon the dressing table with meticulous, agonizing precision.

“You will not speak to Lucy like that,” Emily said, her voice deadly low.

“I speak the truth because no one else in this house will,” Mrs. Douglas retorted, her breath coming in frantic bursts. “The Duke is destined for Lady Anellay. The entire parish knows the alliance is practically signed. A man of his rank will play with you until the season ends. And when his wedding carriage rolls past, Casper will be gone. Casper is sure, Emily. Casper is safe. If you cast him aside for a duke’s passing whim, you will end up with nothing.”

Mrs. Douglas waited, trembling with raw anxiety. But Emily gave her nothing. Not a tear, not an argument, only an impenetrable wall of silence. With a final sharp glare, her mother turned on her heel and pulled the heavy bed chamber door shut with a sharp resounding click. The room fell into an agonizing hush.

Emily stood rigid before the looking glass, her knuckles turning stark white as her fingers gripped the edge of the mahogany table. Behind her, Lucy stepped forward without a sound. She did not cry. She simply walked to Emily’s side, placing a warm, steady hand over Emily’s clenched fingers.

“You didn’t look at her once,” Lucy whispered, her voice tight with an ache meant only for them. “You only use that voice when you are bleeding to death inside.”

A ragged, shuddering breath tore from Emily’s throat. She closed her eyes tightly, pressing her forehead against the cool glass of the mirror as the phantom heat of James’s touch in the gallery ripped through her all over again. A single whisper dropped in a vaulted gallery, an idle boast behind an ivory fan, and two souls were severed without a single harsh truth ever being spoken. London’s gossips moved on within an hour, never knowing their careless poison had left a proud man bleeding, and a terrified woman locking herself behind her own defenses. James Stanley was guilty of stubborn pride and an unyielding will.

But he was not guilty of deceit. From the dark hours of her fever, counting every shallow breath she drew, there had never been another woman in his world. Lord Anellay had visited Berkshire solely to negotiate estate timber. James had never looked at Lady Anellay with anything more than distant courtesy. Yet, because pride demanded silence, and fear demanded protection, the lie took root.

The morning after her mother’s scolding, the front knocker struck with sharp authority. Upstairs, Emily froze beside the window. Downstairs, the butler delivered the rehearsed falsehood. Miss Douglas was asleep, fatigued from her illness, and the family was not receiving callers.

James returned to his carriage with a tight jaw. Two mornings later, he was on the doorstep again, refusing to accept the silence. When the servant offered another polite excuse, James did not leave. He stood on the pavement for nearly an hour, his great coat drenched in the gray drizzle, staring up at the dark glass of the upper floor before retreating to avoid a public scene.

For 14 agonizing days, Emily drifted between her bed chamber and the damp garden paths, hollowed by the war in her chest. She told herself to accept Casper’s safe, easy world, only to recoil from the thought in the next breath. Her heart belonged entirely to the man standing in the rain. Yet every bitter memory of her mother’s warnings whispered that a duke’s affection was a trap. Casper called nearly every afternoon.

Emily sat quietly during these visits, offering little more than tired nods while turning her tea cold. Casper watched her with mounting vigilance. He was not blind. He knew this silence was not modesty. One afternoon, when Emily stepped into the pantry for a fresh kettle, Casper walked to the small table by her work basket. Beneath a linen cloth lay her drawing pad. He lifted the corner. Drawn across the paper in dark, feverish charcoal was the sharp, severe jawline and commanding brow of the Duke of Westfall.