“Good judgment, was it?”

Emily kept her eyes determinately ahead.

“Do not ruin the rescue.”

His soft laugh followed her along the path, and Emily found herself smiling before she could stop the reaction, a realization that proved far more unsettling than the near fall had been.

Emily returned from Venice to find Casper Ingrams sitting in her parents’ drawing room. That in itself was hardly remarkable. Casper had been wandering into their house since he was old enough to reach the biscuit tray. What brought Emily to an abrupt halt in the doorway was the presence of his parents as well. Her mother rose immediately, smoothing down her skirts with uncharacteristic flutter.

“Emily, we thought you would not arrive until much later.”

“So did I,” Emily murmured, stepping into the room.

Casper stood, offering a familiar easy grin that was momentarily the only ordinary thing in sight.

“Welcome home, Em.”

“Thank you.”

Then Emily took in the rest of the scene, the formal tea service laid out for six, her father deep in quiet conversation beside the elder, Mr. Ingrams, her mother seated in conspiratorial closeness to Casper’s mother, and the heavy unified turn of four parental gazes the second she stepped through the door. Emily began peeling off her traveling gloves, taking her time with each button.

“What have I interrupted?”

“Nothing at all, my dear,” her mother said, offering a smile that arrived entirely too quickly.

Beside her, Casper looked down at his boots, and Emily did not miss the slight tightening around his jaw. She took a seat, enduring the polite flurry of opening pleasantries. For several minutes everyone went through the motions of an ordinary neighborly call, inquiring after the crossing from Italy, the success of the Venetian commission, and the weariness of the post chaises. Emily answered evenly, giving them precisely what was asked, and not a syllable more. Then her father cleared his throat. The room fell instantly quiet, and Emily braced herself.

“Your mother and I have been in discussion with the Ingrams while you were abroad,” he began carefully.

Emily looked at him over the rim of her cup.

“About?”

Her mother reached for the teapot, fussing with the silver handle, though no one’s cup was empty.

“About your future, Emily.”

Emily’s gaze shifted straight to Casper. The easy smile had vanished from his face entirely.

“You and Casper have known each other almost your entire lives,” her father pressed on, choosing his words with deliberate weight. “He is well established, thoroughly sensible, and his family is as dear to us as our own.”

“And he cares for you deeply,” her mother added softly.

A thick, suffocating stillness descended over the drawing room. Emily looked from one parent to the other, then to the Ingrams, and finally back to Casper, who held her stare with quiet discomfort.

“You have been discussing marriage,” she said, letting the stark word hang in the air.

No one rushed to deny it. That silence was answer enough. Her mother tried to soften the blow.

“No decision has been made.”

“By whom?”

“Emily?”

“I am asking,” she said, her voice remaining level, “has an arrangement been made?”

“No arrangement has been settled without your consent,” her father said firmly, leaning forward. “We would never do that to you. But we have spoken of the possibilities.”

“I see.”

Emily turned back to Casper.

“How long have you known about these discussions?”

“Not long,” he answered without hesitation. “My parents raised the matter just before your carriage was expected.”

“And?”

“And I informed them there was remarkably little sense in planning a marriage without first consulting the woman expected to be in it.”

It was a classic Casper response, honest, grounded, and entirely fair. Yet it did nothing to soften the sting that everyone around her had been quietly plotting her life the moment her back was turned. Emily stood, gathering her gloves. Her mother looked up with anxious eyes.

“We only ask that you consider him, Emily.”

“I have considered Casper since I was 6 years old.”

Casper lifted a wry brow.

“That sounds terribly promising.”

Emily shot him a quelling look, and he wisely held his tongue. Her father rose as well, holding up a pacifying hand.