“When did the danger end?” she asked without looking up.
“I received word in the autumn of 1814 that Harriet had reached a safer household.”
“Then why did you not write?”
“I feared she might still be found. I feared the subscription would be damaged by a public inquiry. Some of the payment authorizations were issued under my name.”
“And in 1815?”
He was silent.
“Did you know she remained safe?”
“Yes.”
He took another sheet from the packet. It was a discreet notice from a trusted correspondent confirming Harriet’s continued safety in Sussex the previous year. The dates were plain.
Nothing in it justified another year of absolute silence. Eliza laid the sheets carefully beside one another. Her brother’s words, written with care for her future, had been kept from her by a man who considered himself careful.
“You let me wait,” she said.
“Yes.”
“You let me ask whether he might still be alive.”
“I did not know that he had died.”
“But you knew where he had meant to travel. You knew whom he had been helping. You knew enough to offer me a path, and you chose not to.”
“I thought that by acting too soon, I might expose people already in danger.”
“You thought?”
She looked up, tears on her face.
“And because you were a duke, you believed your thoughts could stand in place of everyone else’s choices.”
He absorbed the words without defending himself.
“It explains my silence,” he said at last. “It does not excuse it.”
For one unbearable instant, she wanted to walk toward him. She had come to know the care with which he stood aside, the way he listened when she spoke of her work, the surprising humor he had revealed in Sussex. She could see that he was ashamed. None of those things gave her back the lost months.
“I think I was beginning to love you,” she said so quietly that she had not meant the words to escape.
His face changed as though she had struck him and offered him happiness in the same breath.
“Then I have made the loss greater,” he answered.
Eliza folded William’s letter, put it in her own reticule, and rose. Lady Agnes closed her book.
“I shall continue searching,” Eliza said. “But you will no longer direct the search. You may give me records you are lawfully permitted to share. You may answer questions. You may not decide which truths I am strong enough to hear.”
“I understand.”
“No,” she replied. “I hope you will in time.”
She left with Lady Agnes before the light faded. In the coach, she held William’s letter against her heart. For the first time in nearly 2 years, she had received the words she had begged the world to give her. Their arrival had cost her the fragile trust she had only just begun to place in another man.
Eliza did not return immediately to London. Lady Agnes had already arranged for them to remain in Sussex while the innkeeper’s account was checked, and Eliza would not abandon a promising line of inquiry simply because the Duke had forfeited her trust. The first morning without Sebastian’s company felt oddly longer than the others. She resented that fact.
He had deceived her by withholding a truth that was never his to own. She had made the right decision in leaving him. Yet during breakfast, she caught herself expecting him to make some grave observation about the strength of the tea, and the absence of his voice annoyed her almost as much as the memory of it.
“Affection is not a court judgment,” Lady Agnes said, watching her across the table. “You need not declare every feeling guilty merely because someone has disappointed you.”
“He did more than disappoint me.”
“I know.”
“Then why does my heart insist on remembering the kindness in him?”
“Because kindness and wrongdoing can inhabit the same person, and deciding what to do with that knowledge is among the less pleasant tasks of adulthood.”
Eliza pushed aside her cup.
“I would rather have an easy task.”
“Most of us would.”
They followed the clue of Harriet’s mother’s surname through a parish correspondence address, careful not to place the woman’s whereabouts into the hands of Stroud’s associates. When they finally met her, Harriet Shaw was not a mysterious woman in a hooded cloak. She was a widow with tired eyes, careful handwriting, and a habit of checking that doors were properly closed before speaking.