“I did not write this.”
“Eleanor.”
“I did not write this, Alexander. Look. Look at the hand.”
She held it against the window, her voice rising, becoming precise.
“I make a capital E with a loop at the top, like this.”
She traced it in the air.
“And I never cross my t so far to the right. I would never sign myself E. Whitmore to you. Never. Who wrote this? Who wrote this?”
Even as she asked, she knew. She had seen that hand every day for twelve years on shopping lists and notes left upon the hall table.
“Eleanor, Mrs. Pomfrey is coming on Thursday. Wear gray.”
The same slant, the same heavy, impatient downward stroke.
“My aunt,” she whispered. “My aunt wrote this.”
The Duke grew very still.
“Every letter I wrote to you,” Eleanor said slowly, as the pieces fitted together, cold and terrible, “I gave to her to post. Every letter that came into this house went to her first on a silver tray. She sorted them. She always sorted them.”
She pressed the forged letter against her breast.
“She never sent mine. She never gave me yours. She wrote this so that you would stop, and told me about Lisbon so that I would stop. Oh, God. Alexander. Twelve years.”
Her knees gave way. She did not fall, because he crossed the distance in two strides, caught her, and held her upright. Then he simply held her as she wept against his shoulder, as she had not wept when her father died, when her aunt told her about Lisbon, or on any day since. Twelve years of tears came at once, soaking the fine black cloth of a duke’s evening coat. He said nothing. One hand cradled the back of her head, and she felt his uneven breathing against her hair.
When she could breathe again, she drew back a little and looked up.
“Why? Why would she do it? I was nothing to her. A poor niece. Why go to so much trouble to keep me from you?”
His expression became grave.
“You were not nothing to her. You kept her house and taught her daughter without wages. And there is a worse reason. When I became heir to the title, Clarissa was still a child. But your aunt thinks in decades. I suspect she hoped one day to see her own daughter Duchess of Westbrook. She could hardly allow her penniless niece to get there first.”
Eleanor stared at him.
“But Clarissa is engaged to Mr. Fairley.”
“She became engaged,” the Duke said dryly, “three days after I declined your aunt’s rather pointed invitation to escort Miss Crane to the Michaelmas assembly. I imagine Mr. Fairley is the consolation prize.”
Despite everything, despite the tears on her face and the crumpled forgery in her hand, Eleanor gave a small, startled laugh. He smiled at the sound. For a moment he looked exactly like the young man on her father’s study floor.
“I have missed that sound,” he said softly.