Numbers appeared, failed to correspond, and were checked again. A supposed delivery of blankets exceeded the quantity booked as received. A shipment charged twice had one carrier acknowledgement. Payments certified to beneficiaries did not align with the dated receipt of the widow Eliza had met. Stroud’s office had been sending altered copies to the charity, while the independent warehouse retained its ordinary book.
“This is enough to require a full examination,” one trustee observed.
“It is enough to ask difficult questions,” Eliza replied. “I should not like to accuse a man of a figure that has merely been copied badly.”
She understood the danger of an error better than anyone. One slip of her brush on a miniature could transform a likeness. One invented character in her transcription could transform a suspicion into something that looked like proof.
At a gathering preceding the formal meeting, Sir Lionel approached her beneath a portrait of a long-dead statesman.
“You are remarkably persistent for a young woman whose own conduct has attracted so much attention,” he said.
“My conduct has no effect upon whether a carrier made one delivery or two.”
“A reputation is a delicate possession, Miss Merryweather.”
“So is an account book when entrusted to gentlemen who find inconvenient figures offensive.”
His smile narrowed.
“You imagine a clever reply will make you respectable.”
“I have no intention of asking you to decide that. I shall ask the trustees to decide whether the figures are correct.”
She left him standing beneath the portrait, her hands cold but her steps steady. Sebastian heard of the exchange afterward. His first instinct was to offer his name as a shield. He recognized that impulse for what it was, an old habit wearing the clothing of protection. He did not propose marriage to stop the gossip.
He did not purchase the next commission Stroud’s friends threatened to withdraw. He wrote to the solicitor asking that any question concerning Eliza’s professional conduct be addressed only through her proper references, not through his title. Then the independent trustees informed him of another discovery. Among the authorized records was an approval for a disputed payment bearing his own genuine signature.
It had been signed when he failed to verify the invoices beneath it. The approval did not prove that he knowingly diverted funds. It proved that his confidence in subordinates had helped the false accounts pass without adequate scrutiny. Sebastian examined the copy the trustees showed him.
“Yes,” he said, “that is my signature.”
“We can distinguish negligence from deliberate fraud in our account of the matter,” the solicitor advised.
“You should distinguish them,” Sebastian replied. “But you must not omit the negligence. Preserve the page with the others. If we remove the evidence that shames me, we shall only repeat the mistake that brought us here.”
When Eliza learned what he had said, she felt no sudden impulse to forget his silence. She felt something quieter. For the first time, he had accepted that a record could be true, even when it made him look less worthy of admiration. It was a lesson William had tried to teach them both.