They walked out of the church into a bright, cold December morning with the bells ringing and the village children throwing dried rose petals because there were no fresh ones to be had. And at the garden wall of the old vicarage, which they had to pass on the way to the carriage, the Duke stopped. The apple tree was still there, bare now in winter, its branches black against the pale sky, but still there.
“Do you remember?” he said.
“I remember,” she said.
“It was raining. You were soaked through. You’d lost a shoe in the long grass, and you were laughing so hard you couldn’t stand.”
His voice was very soft.
“I thought I had never seen anyone so beautiful in my life. I still think it.”
“I was 18,” Eleanor said. “I am 30 now.”
“Yes,” said the Duke of Ashford. “And more beautiful now, because now I know what it cost you to keep smiling.”
He kissed her hand, the one with the pearl ring.
“Your aunt thought 30 was a shameful thing. I think 30 is a woman who has been tested and has not broken. I would not trade one year of you, Eleanor, not even the years I missed. They made you who you are.”
That night, at Ashford Abbey, in front of a great fire in the library he had filled with books for her, enough to stack on the stairs and under the beds, and even if she wished, in the oven, the new Duchess of Ashford sat on the hearthrug with a bundle of old letters in her lap. Not his letters, her own. The 12 letters she had written to him all those years ago and given to her aunt to post, and which had lain unopened in a rosewood box for 11 years.
“I want you to have them,” she said, and held them out to him. “They were always yours. You should have had them a long time ago.”
He took them from her. He looked at the first one for a long moment, at her handwriting on the front, the careful, looping E that her father had taught her. Then he broke the seal and unfolded it and began to read. She watched his face as he read.
She watched it change. She saw him reach the place where she had written about her father’s last words. She saw him reach the place where she had written,
“I am frightened, Alexander. I am alone, and I do not know what will become of me, but I am still waiting. I will always be waiting.”
She saw his eyes fill, and his mouth tremble, and his hand rise to cover his face. She moved closer and put her arms around him and held him the way he had held her among the orange trees, and did not say anything at all.
Outside, it had begun to snow. Soft and silent over the park and the lake and the long avenue of old oaks, covering everything in white as though the world were being made new.
They read every letter that night, his and hers, side by side in the order they had been written. When they had finished and the windows had begun to turn gray, the Duke set the last letter on top of the others and looked at his wife.
“12 years,” he said quietly. “41 letters and 12 letters. 53 letters, and not one of them reached where it was meant to go.”
“They’ve reached now,” said Eleanor.
“Yes,” he said. “They’ve reached now.”
She leaned her head against his shoulder, and he put his arm around her, and they sat together in the gray light, watching the snow fall.