“You should have waited,” Eleanor said, and from somewhere deep and long buried, a flame of anger rose up in her, hot and astonishing. “You say that to me? I waited, Alexander. I wrote to you every month for a year after Papa died, when I had no one in the world, and you never answered. Not one line. And then I heard you had found a lady with a fortune in Lisbon. You might have written once, just once, to say goodbye. Instead, I have sat at her table for 12 years as the poor relation who was jilted by a soldier. And now you walk into her dining room and say you’ve been waiting for me? Waiting for what?”

Her voice broke on the last word. She turned away again, ashamed, and gripped the edge of an orange tub with both hands. Behind her, there was a long silence. Then the Duke said very slowly,

“Eleanor, what lady in Lisbon?”

“Don’t,” she said. “Please, don’t pretend.”

“I am not pretending. I’d swear to you on my brother’s grave. There was never any lady in Lisbon. There was never any lady anywhere. And I did write to you every week as I promised from every camp and every billet. I wrote until… Until I received your letter.”

She turned around.

“My letter?”

He was already reaching inside his coat. He drew out a small, flat leather case, worn, soft, and dark with age, and opened it. Inside was a single folded sheet of paper, yellowed and creased.

“I have carried this,” he said, “for 11 years through the peninsula, through Waterloo, to punish myself, I think.”

He held it out to her.

“Read it.”

She took it with trembling fingers. She unfolded it and moved closer to the window where the moonlight fell brightest. The letter was short.

“Mr. Thorne, I write to ask that you cease your correspondence. My circumstances have changed since my father’s death. I have received an offer of marriage from a gentleman of property in this county, and I have accepted him. I hope you will understand that our acquaintance was a youthful folly and that you will not attempt to contact me again. I wish you well in your profession. E. Whitmore.”

Eleanor read it twice, then a third time. Then she looked up at him and her face in the moonlight was white as paper.

“I did not write this,” she said.

“Eleanor.”

“I did not write this, Alexander. Look at it. Look at the hand.”

She held it up to the window, her voice rising. She was very particular.

“I make my capital E with a loop at the top like this,” and she traced it in the air with her finger, “and I never cross my T’s so far to the right, and I would never ever sign myself E. Whitmore to you. Never. Who wrote this? Who wrote this?”

But even as she asked, she knew. She had seen that hand every day for 12 years on shopping lists and notes left on the hall table.

“Eleanor, Mrs. Pomfrey is coming Thursday. Wear the gray.”

That same slope, that same heavy, impatient downstroke.

“My aunt,” she whispered, “my aunt wrote this.”

The Duke had gone very still.

“Every letter I wrote to you,” Eleanor said slowly, as the pieces fell into place, cold and terrible, “I gave to her to post. And every letter that came to this house came to her first on a silver tray. She sorted it. She always sorted it.”

She pressed the forged letter to her heart.