“Merely offering a warning, Briarwick. She damaged a horse in my care and was dismissed.”
“You have documents to support deliberate damage?”
“Her dismissal is a matter of record.”
“A dismissal is not proof of the reason asserted for it.”
One of the visitors studied his gloves. Another made a small noise of disapproval. Vane had expected the Duke to accept a quiet warning and remove the woman before it became awkward. Rowan’s refusal left him with a choice between producing evidence and retreating. He chose the latter, though his expression promised that the matter would not end there.
As the party returned to the house, Mr. Talbot, a landowner who supplied sheltered grazing and winter hay, drew Rowan aside.
“I value our arrangement,” he said, “but Vane has many clients. I would dislike to be caught between you. We ought to revisit our terms before the next renewal.”
“You are free to revisit them. We shall be free to decide whether to accept.”
Talbot’s lips pressed together. The exchange lasted scarcely half a minute. Its consequences would occupy weeks.
Lydia remained at the stable after the visitors departed. Rowan found her checking Sundown’s water, though there was nothing wrong with it.
“You need not pretend his remarks did not wound you,” Rowan said.
“I have had practice pretending.”
“He made an accusation without evidence, and everyone heard it.”
“They heard your defense as well, which will make some of them more curious.”
He reached for her hand before remembering himself. His fingers closed around hers for a breath. Lydia looked down at their hands, then gently withdrew.
“Your Grace,” she murmured, “if someone had seen us, they would not ask whether you meant me harm. They would ask what I had done to invite your notice.”
Rowan felt the humiliation of having endangered her by the very tenderness he wished to offer.
“I beg your pardon.”
“I know you did not mean to hurt me. That does not mean others will be kind.”
That night he spoke with Mrs. Finch. She confirmed that servants had already begun to wonder what place Lydia would have in the household when her contract ended. The housekeeper did not condemn Lydia. She insisted that the Duke recognize the power of his position.
“If you mean only to be generous,” she said, “be generous in ways that leave her free. If you mean something else, Your Grace must decide whether you are prepared to take responsibility for it.”
For a man accustomed to decisive orders, the question was remarkably difficult. He could rebuild a roof after a storm, find a steward for a vacant farm, and calculate the cost of a new breeding line. He could not yet imagine asking Lydia to stand beside him as Duchess before the people who had already begun discussing her behind their hands. The prospect did not trouble him because she was unworthy. It troubled him because he knew the cruelty hidden inside the word worthy. And because a Duke could neither command society’s affection nor bear its contempt on another person’s behalf.