She told him. She had not meant to say more than three sentences, but he asked. And then he asked again. And his questions were not the questions of a man being gracious to a servant to spite his mother. They were the questions of a man who wanted the answer.

Did the honey keep the linen from sticking? Did it matter which honey? How long would it hold before it turned? What did it cost?

“In Spain,” he said at last, “we had a surgeon who did it. Bedos. Everybody laughed at him. He lost fewer men than the others by a great deal, and he could never say why, and it made him miserable, because he was a man who liked reasons.”

He was looking at the candles rather than at her.

“I have thought of him perhaps a hundred times. I never once thought to ask a person who kept the bees.”

“It is the water, Your Grace,” Thurza said.

“What is?”

“Why it does not spoil. Honey is thirsty. My mother said it drinks whatever is put near it, and what is thirsty enough cannot rot. I do not know if that is the true reason. It is the reason I was given, and it has never yet failed me.”

Horatio looked at her for three full seconds.

“That is a better answer than Bedos ever got,” he said.

The dinner went on for 2 hours and 40 minutes. He talked to her for the whole of it, not without pause and not without turning twice to answer Lady Cecily on his other side in six words and eight. But he came back each time the way a man comes back to a fire. They talked about the fever at Cold Hope three winters ago and what the cottages there were roofed with and how many families were left in them.

They talked about the lime walk. They talked about mead and about the price of sugar and about whether the west orchard could be brought back. Thurza said that it could in four years if the trees were headed back hard and the hives were carried up to the top corner in April.

“4 years?” the Duke said.

“Yes, Your Grace.”

“Most people tell me two.”

“Most people are not going to be standing in the orchard in 4 years,” Thurza said before she could stop herself.

There was a silence. Then the Duke of Carsley laughed out loud for the first time since he had come home. At the other end of the table, his mother sat with her hand quite still on the stem of her glass. She had made a joke. She had made it carefully in front of the right people.

Now it was being taken away from her one civil sentence at a time at her own table by her own son. And it was being taken in the hearing of a woman she had brought 140 miles to marry him. At 8 the ladies rose. Thurza rose with them because she did not know what else to do. And the Duke of Carsley stood up.

He stood up as he would have stood for a duchess. He held the back of her chair while she came out of it. Two footmen saw him do it. Lady Cecily saw him do it. His mother saw him do it and did not move at all.

“Miss Renmont,” he said. “Thank you. The library is at the end of the North Passage. It is unlocked.”

Thurza did not go to the library that night. She went down the back stairs and through the kitchen where seven people stopped talking at once and out across the yard in her mother’s green gown with her shoes in her hand. By 6 the next morning the whole of Holmfall knew and by 9 the whole of Holmfall had decided what it thought and the two things were not the same in any two rooms of the house. In the stable yard, it was the best thing that had happened since the peace. In the servants’ hall, it was more complicated.