“The fire wants coal, I think,” said Cecily, and rang the bell. The ladies left within the quarter hour. They did not finish their tea.

“Thirty-one years,” said Mrs. Hollis, shutting the door. “And I have never once seen a Ventnor leave a cup half drunk.”

The duke’s steward kept the lead rents in a book that had not been added since Martinmas. Cecily asked to see it on the second afternoon as a courtesy to her own employment. By dusk she had found 11 pounds and 4 shillings entered under the wrong quarter.

“I do not see why that matters,” said the steward.

“It will matter again in March,” said Cecily.

The steward, who had kept the book for 19 years, looked at her as though a horse had spoken.

“She is right,” said the Duke from the doorway.

He said it in the tone of a man who has been waiting some while to say it to somebody.

Mr. Sutherby came on the third afternoon, riding a hired horse and carrying a japanned box. He was 70, shrunken, with a nose like a reproachful quill. The box held the trust’s quarterly statements, the farm book, and the passbook from the Ravensmore Bank.

“I have written to Your Grace 19 times,” said Mr. Sutherby. “I received one answer.”

“Which declined,” said the Duke.

“Which declined.”

“I wrote none.”

“Then somebody has been writing in your name.”

The old man sat down heavily.

“I rather feared it.”

“Miss Brandreth will examine the accounts.”

“Alone?” said Mr. Sutherby.

“She will want a table, a lamp, and no assistants,” said the Duke. “I have the impression she works better so.”

She did. For 3 hours the library held the scratch of her pen and the small sounds of men trying not to disturb her. The Duke read across the hearth or held a book in front of his face. Mrs. Hollis brought tea with no sugar in it.

Nobody had told her how Cecily took it. The Duke had asked once, in passing, and had not asked again. That made three.

At the end of the third hour, Cecily laid down the pen.

“I shall read it aloud,” she said. “Interrupt me only if I am wrong.”

Nobody interrupted her.

“The farm book gives 1,310 pounds in annual rents. The statements deliver 890. The difference is 420 pounds a year, which is 32% of every rent paid by every tenant. Over 7 years, that is £2,940.”

The pen rolled an inch on the blotter.

“Timber from Brandreth Wood, sold in 1838 for £1,220, entered at 340. That is 880.”

“A loan to the estate of £600, which no bank has any record of lending, charged at 5% for 7 years. That is £210 in interest, and 810 with the principal. The balance, Your Grace, is £4,630.”

Her voice did not move. She might have been naming a stranger’s debts.

“How long did that take?” said the duke.

“Three hours and 10 minutes.”

“Sutherby?”

“It took me 5 years of being lied to by post,” said Mr. Sutherby. “And I never once got the sum.”

The duke sat up with the figures after the house had gone to bed. He read them once, and then he read them again with a care that was almost hostile. There was no error. He had looked for one the way a man looks for a door out of a room. She had said the sum in the voice of somebody reading out a stranger’s debts.

Not one flicker. He had been looking for the flicker. He had met it in everyone who had ever been robbed. She was not without it.

She was keeping it somewhere he could not see, in a place that shut with a key. He found that he wanted her to be right. It was a small, ugly, unfamiliar thing, wanting, and he would have preferred a fever. He had wanted nothing for years.