“Darling, she’s a scullery maid.”

“She doesn’t speak of a duke as though they’ve shared his supper.” Her fingers tightened on the curtain. “He’s been odd for weeks, asking about the accounts, asking about the west wing. If someone in this house has been whispering to him—”

“Then we deal with her,” Fenwick said lightly. “Quietly. By Sunday.”

The duke went very still. What he did next surprised even him. He didn’t storm in. Every instinct told him to. He had a title, a famous temper, and he could have emptied that room with one sentence.

But a man who bursts in gets an apology and a performance. A man who waits gets the truth.

“Show me where she goes.”

Dunmore led him down the servants’ passage, past worn steps that smelled of wood smoke and lye. The duke had owned this house for nine years and had never once walked it. The scullery door stood ajar: lamplight, the scrape of a basin. Elspeth was at the pump, running cold water over her palm, wincing now that no one could see. A girl no older than twelve sat on an upturned bucket, crying into her sleeve.

“It’s only a cup, Tam,” Elspeth said softly. “Cups break.”

“She’ll say it was me.”

“She won’t. I’ll say it was the draft.”

She bound her hand with a strip of linen and pressed a small cloth parcel into the girl’s lap.

“Now eat that before Cook sees. I saved you the end of the pie.”

The duke stood in the dark and watched a girl bleeding from his guest’s cruelty give away her own supper. Then Elspeth reached into her apron, past the china, and drew out something small and folded. She held it up to the lamp. He knew that paper. Same cream stock, same torn corner as the six words burning a hole in his coat pocket.

For a moment, the duke honestly thought the floor had tilted. Same cream paper, same torn corner. He didn’t need to take the note from his coat to be sure. He had read those six words so many times on the road that he could see them with his eyes shut. Come home before you are expected.

“Dunmore.” It barely made a sound. “Look at me.”

The old butler had been studying his candle for some time. Now, like a man putting down a heavy trunk, he lifted his eyes.

“Forgive me, Your Grace.”

“You sent it to my club.”

“I did, sir.”

“You knew who wrote it.”

“She wrote four. The first three ran to pages: names, dates, sums of money. I told her no duke in England reads pages from a scullery maid. So she cut it down to what a man might read standing in a doorway. Six words. She was rather pleased with them.”

Inside the scullery, Elspeth knelt at the hearth and slid a brick from the chimney breast. The duke caught a glimpse of the hollow behind it. Bundle upon bundle of paper tied with kitchen twine. She tucked the new page on top.