A man walking in now would get a laugh, an excuse, and a tearful performance from Cordelia while the ledgers sat in the chimney waiting for the first match. She wanted him to see all of it, even this. He sank back down, shaking, and hated her for being right. Fenwick released her hand with a little pat, as if smoothing a tablecloth. Then he bent close, so close the duke almost missed it.

“I’ll tell you what interests me most, Wren. I know what name you were born under.”

Elspeth’s face went white.

“I wonder what His Grace would say if he heard it. Shall I say it now, in front of the child?”

“Don’t.”

“Ah,” he whispered, and smiled. “So it is true.”

Behind the flour barrels, the Duke of Whitmore was about to learn the one thing she’d refused to tell him.

“Callaway,” Fenwick said. “Elspeth Callaway, daughter of Edmund Callaway, late steward of Ravenscar Park.”

The name dropped behind the flour barrels like a stone down a well. The duke knew it. Not the face, never the face, but he knew that name at the bottom of the oldest ledgers in the estate office, in a careful, steady hand. And just beneath one of them, his own signature, scrawled nine years ago, three days after he buried his father. A dismissal, theft.

A stack of papers pushed in front of him, and he’d signed without reading because he wanted to be anywhere alone. The family was turned out of the steward’s cottage that December.

“Your father robbed this house blind, Wren,” Fenwick went on, almost kindly. “Died in debtors’ jail, didn’t he? And here you are, polishing the silver of the man who signed him there. Revenge is such a patient hobby.” He tapped the crumpled letter against her shoulder. “So when I take these to a magistrate, who do you imagine he’ll believe? A lord, or a thief’s daughter with a grudge?”

That was the trap, and the duke saw it all at once. Every page in that chimney could be called spite, forgery, a servant’s fantasy.

“My father never stole a shilling,” Elspeth said. Her voice shook, but she didn’t. “And you know it.”

“Prove it.”

“I will.”

“Gone by dawn, Wren, or the magistrate hears the other version.”

Fenwick tucked the letter into his waistcoat and strolled out, whistling. The passage went silent. Tam had fled to bed. Elspeth stood alone, staring at her bleeding palm.

“You can come out, Your Grace.”

He rose slowly from behind the barrels. Eleven thousand acres of famous temper and not one word.

“That’s why I couldn’t tell you. I didn’t want to be one more person in this house asking you for something. I wanted you to see.”

“Say his name again.”

“Edmund Callaway.”

“I signed it in four minutes.” The duke’s voice scraped. “I remember because I watched the clock. I wanted to go and be alone with my grief, and a man’s life was in the way.”