He had inherited them and he was proud of them. That was what she believed, walking back to the house in the dusk. She was wrong.

He found her in the library at 9 that evening while the house was at cards. The brown paper lay open on the table in front of her.

“The groom found this in your mother’s saddle,” she said. “I thought you should have it back.”

He looked at it as a man looks at a letter he has dreaded for years.

“You copied them,” she said. “Every word. Your father wrote them and your mother kept them and wrote it at the bottom as if it were a thing to be proud of.”

“She was not proud of it,” said the Duke.

He put both hands flat on the table, either side of the paper, and looked at it rather than at her.

“My father wrote those rules the week he married my mother,” he said. “She kept every one of them for one-and-twenty years. She did not hunt, though she had ridden since she was five. She did not laugh, and I did not once hear her laugh in my life. She did not contradict him, not at table, not anywhere. He trained me the same way, rule by rule, until I could stand in a full room and show nothing. When my grandmother told me to write down what I required in a wife, I wrote down his list exactly because it was the only description of a duchess I had ever been given. I wrote it so that no woman with any sense would have me. I wrote it so that any woman who could keep it would be warned. Tomorrow is the hunt ball. My grandmother expects me to open it with the woman I mean to marry. I am asking you to open it with me. You may refuse. You may walk out of this room and take the York coach on Saturday. Your 40 guineas are yours, whatever you answer. Nothing I have given you is withdrawn.”

The library was very quiet. Somewhere below them, a woman laughed at the card table. A thin, high laugh with nothing in it. Rosamund looked at the brown paper. “Kept all.” She thought of a woman who had ridden since she was five, folding that list into a saddle she would never use.

She had written those two words at the bottom so that someone someday would know what it had cost. The 10th rule was that she should not be seen to weep. She did not decide to break it. It broke. One tear and then another running down her face in the candlelight of a duke’s library in front of the Duke.

She did not wipe them away. She had not cried in front of anyone for 8 years, and she found she had forgotten how to be ashamed of it. The Duke did not look away. He did not offer a handkerchief or a word or a hand. He simply stood there and let her do it as if it were a thing she had every right to.