“Should we plant more beans?”
“Would your mother have put sage in the chicken stew?”
That last question stopped Hannah. Margaret looked uncomfortable.
“I remember Robert saying she cooked it differently.”
Hannah swallowed.
“Yes. She used sage.”
Margaret nodded.
“Would you show me?”
Hannah did. It was strange. Painful.
Tender. They cooked together without mentioning Christmas. Later, when Margaret tasted the stew, she said,
“It is better.”
Hannah looked at her.
“My mother would enjoy hearing you say that.”
Margaret smiled faintly.
“I imagine she would.”
Robert also tried. He did not know how to repair emotional damage, so he repaired physical things. He replaced a cracked window in Hannah’s room.
Built her a new shelf. Fixed the loose board outside her door. Finally Hannah told him,
“Pa, if you fix one more thing in my room, there won’t be anything left that belongs to the original house.”
He stood holding a hammer.
“I’m trying.”
She softened.
“I know.”
He sat on the edge of her chair. For a long moment, he studied the hammer.
“I failed you that day.”
Hannah did not rescue him from the sentence. He continued.
“I wanted peace so badly that I let you carry the cost of it.”
Hannah’s throat tightened. That was the truth. Not that there had been no chair.
Not that Margaret had spoken thoughtlessly. The real wound was that Robert had wanted comfort more than he had wanted to protect his daughter. He looked at her.
“I should have stood up.”
“Yes.”
“I’m sorry.”
Hannah nodded.
“I know.”
“Can you forgive me?”
She thought before answering.
“I think forgiveness is different from pretending nothing happened.”
Robert’s eyes lowered.
“Yes.”
“I forgive you.”
He looked up.
“But I need you to understand I won’t keep making myself smaller just to make this house peaceful.”
Her father swallowed.
“You shouldn’t.”
That mattered. Hannah leaned against him. Robert put one arm around her.
For a little while, she was eight years old again. Then she was twenty-five. Both could be true.
CHAPTER 7: THE HARD SUMMER
Summer arrived dry. Too dry. By June, grass in the western pasture had turned pale. By July, the creek ran low.
By August, every rancher in the valley watched the sky as though clouds were money. Hard seasons revealed people. Some became mean. Some became frightened.
Some became generous. William became busier. He moved cattle farther north to save grazing land. He sold several older animals early rather than risk losing them later.
Hannah saw him less. When he did visit, dust covered his clothes and exhaustion shadowed his eyes. One evening he arrived after dark. Hannah was washing dishes.
“You ate?”
“Yes.”
She looked at him.
“You’re lying.”