“I thought it was temporary.”
“It was.”
She looked up.
“But you still let me walk outside.”
Robert’s mouth opened. Nothing came. Behind him, Margaret stood in the doorway. Her face was pale.
“Must we do this in front of everyone?”
Hannah almost laughed. In front of everyone. As though that were the cruel part. William rose.
“I’ll go.”
Hannah looked at him quickly. He gave her a small nod. Not abandonment. Space. He picked up his gift and handed it to her.
“This was for you.”
Hannah stared at the parcel.
“For me?”
“Yes.”
Margaret’s eyes moved from William to Hannah. William continued,
“Merry Christmas.”
“You didn’t have to bring me anything.”
“I know.”
That was such a William answer that Hannah smiled despite everything. He put his gloves back on. Robert frowned.
“You’re leaving?”
William glanced at Hannah.
“I came to have Christmas dinner with friends.”
No one spoke. William did not need to say more. He stepped off the porch. Hannah stood.
“Wait.”
He turned. She did not know what she intended to say. Thank you felt too small.
I’m embarrassed felt too weak. I will remember this for the rest of my life felt terrifying. So she said,
“You forgot your biscuit.”
William smiled.
“You keep it.”
He mounted his horse. Then he rode away across the bright winter yard. Hannah watched until he disappeared behind the cottonwoods. When she turned around, Margaret was still standing in the doorway.
“You’ve humiliated me.”
The words landed harder than Hannah expected. Robert turned.
“Margaret.”
“What else would you call it? Half the family watched William Cole sit outside because Hannah made this into some great insult.”
Hannah stared at her.
“I didn’t ask him to sit.”
“You didn’t discourage him.”
“I told him to go inside.”
Margaret crossed her arms.
“And I suppose he just happened to arrive at the perfect moment.”
Hannah’s face went cold.
“What are you saying?”
“Enough,”
Robert said. But Margaret was upset now, and upset people sometimes opened doors they had kept shut for years.
“I’m saying you always know how to make yourself look mistreated.”
Hannah felt as though the porch had tilted beneath her feet. Samuel appeared behind Margaret.
“Ma.”
“Go inside.”
“No.”
“Samuel.”
He moved beside Hannah. The gesture was small. But Hannah saw it. So did Margaret.
Her face changed. Clara appeared too. Then little Thomas. One by one, the children stood in the doorway behind their mother, looking frightened and confused.
Hannah did not want that. Not on Christmas. Not ever. She lifted the parcel William had given her.
“I’m going to my room.”
Margaret said nothing. Robert stepped toward her.
“Hannah.”
She stopped. He looked older than he had that morning.