Then another. Then replaced both. Finally, she faced him.

“You’ve been here often.”

William’s voice remained calm.

“Have I?”

“You know you have.”

“Yes.”

Hannah stopped rolling dough. Margaret looked directly at him.

“What are your intentions?”

“Margaret,”

Hannah said. William did not look embarrassed. He did not look amused either. He placed the cup down.

“My intentions are respectful.”

“That is not an answer.”

“It’s the answer Hannah is entitled to hear before anyone else.”

Hannah’s heart stumbled. Margaret stared. William looked at Hannah. Neither spoke for several seconds. Then he stood.

“I should check on that mare.”

He took his coat. At the doorway he paused.

“Hannah?”

“Yes?”

“I’ll be by Sunday after church.”

Margaret’s eyes narrowed. Hannah said,

“All right.”

He left. The door closed. Margaret turned.

“So now everyone in this valley gets to watch you court William Cole.”

Hannah resumed rolling dough.

“Apparently.”

“You think this is funny?”

“No.”

“You must understand what people will say.”

Hannah stopped. Something had changed in her since Christmas. Not all at once. But enough. She laid the rolling pin aside.

“People already say things.”

Margaret stiffened.

“Hannah…”

“I spent years trying to behave so carefully that you would never have a reason to dislike me.”

Margaret’s face changed. Hannah continued before courage failed.

“I worked. I stayed quiet. I helped with the children. I never asked Pa to choose between us. I never reminded anyone that this was my mother’s kitchen before it was yours.”

“Hannah.”

“But you still found reasons.”

Margaret’s eyes flashed.

“You think I have treated you badly?”

“Yes.”

The word hung between them. Hannah had never said it before. Margaret looked genuinely stunned. Hannah’s voice softened.

“I don’t think you’re evil. I don’t think you planned it every morning. But yes. You treated me as though the best thing I could do was make life easier for everyone else and need nothing myself.”

Margaret stared at the dough.

“When I married your father, you hated me.”

“I was twelve.”

“You never wanted me here.”

“My mother had died.”

“So had the life I knew.”

Hannah frowned. Margaret’s voice trembled.

“My first husband left me with debts. I came here knowing half the valley thought I had married your father because he owned land.”

Hannah had known Margaret had been married before. She had never known about the debts. Margaret continued.

“You looked at me with your mother’s eyes. Every time I moved a chair or changed a curtain, I felt I was being measured against a dead woman.”

Hannah’s anger shifted, not disappearing but changing shape.

“I was a child.”

“I know.”

“You were the adult.”

Margaret closed her eyes.

“I know that too.”

It was the first honest conversation they had ever had. It did not heal anything. Not yet. But honesty created a place where healing might someday stand. Margaret picked up one of the bowls again.

“I should start supper.”

“I’m making biscuits.”

“I can see that.”

Hannah almost smiled. Margaret hesitated.