Extra chairs had been brought from bedrooms and the porch. Children squeezed between adults. Hannah placed the roast in the center.

“Beautiful,”

Amos said.

“Hannah did nearly all of it,”

Robert said. Margaret’s eyes flickered toward him. Hannah smiled.

“Everyone helped.”

It was not true. But Christmas seemed the wrong day to count labor. She carried in the potatoes.

Then bread. Then gravy. Then vegetables.

Finally, Hannah went to the kitchen and filled her own plate. When she returned, the room had changed. Every chair was occupied.

Samuel had squeezed between Amos and Clara. Elizabeth’s youngest boy was sitting on a crate. Robert looked around.

“Oh.”

It was only one word. But Hannah heard everything inside it. Margaret looked over the table.

“No room.”

Hannah waited. Surely someone would move. Robert half rose.

“We can…”

Margaret spoke before he finished.

“Hannah can eat on the porch.”

Silence. Not complete silence. A spoon touched a plate. The fire cracked.

Thomas whispered something to Clara. But it felt silent to Hannah. Her father stared at Margaret.

“What?”

“There’s no room,”

Margaret repeated.

“The children are already squeezed together. Hannah won’t mind.”

Hannah looked at her father. That was the moment she remembered for years afterward. Not Margaret’s words. Her father’s face. His hesitation.

He could have stood. He could have said no. He could have taken his plate outside himself. He could have made space somehow.

Instead, Robert looked from Hannah to the crowded table as though searching for a solution that required no courage. Hannah understood. And because she loved him, the understanding hurt worse. She forced a smile.

“It’s all right.”

Samuel stood immediately.

“You take mine.”

“No.”

“Hannah…”

“Sit.”

“I can eat outside.”

“You’ll freeze before you finish chewing.”

“So will you.”

Hannah’s smile trembled.

“I’m older.”

“That doesn’t make you warmer.”

Amos coughed into his hand. Robert finally pushed back his chair.

“I’ll bring another…”

“There isn’t another,”

Margaret said.

“Unless you want someone sitting on the washstand.”

Hannah lifted her plate.

“Pa. It’s fine.”

He looked at her. She made herself smile. That gave him permission. She hated herself a little for giving it.

“All right,”

Robert said softly.

“Just until someone finishes.”

Someone. Not him.

Hannah turned before her face betrayed her. The kitchen felt strangely peaceful compared with the dining room. She took her shawl from its peg. Then she stepped outside. Cold air struck her cheeks.

The porch boards were dusted with powdery snow. Hannah brushed off the top step with one hand and sat. Through the window behind her came the blurred shapes of people passing dishes. She could hear laughter.

Hannah balanced the plate on her knees. Steam rose from the potatoes she had peeled. The biscuit she had baked rested beside a slice of goose she had basted for hours. For some reason, that nearly made her laugh.

She had prepared a feast at which there was no place for her. Hannah broke the biscuit. She did not eat it. Her eyes burned.