Then the forged letters arrived.
On the morning of Charlotte’s ball, James summoned Eleanor to his study, devastated. Six letters had been delivered to his club, with copies sent to major households across London. The handwriting looked horrifyingly like Eleanor’s. The letters described an affair that had never existed with the late Duke of Ashborne.
Eleanor swore she had not written them, and James believed her. But society would not. The handwriting was nearly perfect, and by evening the scandal sheets would have them. Eleanor immediately thought of Charlotte and decided to leave London before the ball began, hoping her absence would protect her niece.
At Ashborne House, Alexander read the scandal sheet and felt fury rise through him. The accusations were absurd. His uncle had been devoted to his late wife, and the letters were clearly a malicious fabrication. Alexander summoned his solicitor and the best handwriting expert in London.
The expert confirmed that the letters were false. The ink was too modern for the dates, the paper bore a watermark from the previous year, and small inconsistencies proved that the handwriting had been copied. Still, the ball was only hours away, and society had already seen the letters.
Alexander rode immediately to Whitmore House.
He found Eleanor surrounded by half-packed trunks. She told him he should distance himself from her or risk destroying his own standing. Alexander took her by the shoulders and told her that he loved her, and that nothing had changed. He would prove the letters false and expose whoever had done this.
Eleanor whispered that there was no time. Charlotte’s ball was that night. Alexander told her not to attend if she felt she could not, but not to flee London. Instead, she would stay at Ashborne House under his protection. It was irregular, but he did not care.
That evening, Eleanor sat alone in Alexander’s library while Charlotte’s debut ball began above. She could hear the distant music and the murmur of society gathering to witness what they expected would be a social disaster. Alexander came to her before entering the ballroom and kissed her forehead. “Stay here,” he said. “No matter what you hear, trust me.”
The ballroom glittered with London’s elite. No one had dared refuse the duke’s invitation. They came to whisper, watch, and judge. Alexander entered alone, and the orchestra fell silent. He walked to the center of the room and raised his hand.
Before the festivities could begin, he spoke of Lady Eleanor Whitmore. He declared that the letters were malicious forgeries and that experts would prove it. Then he promised that anyone who repeated lies about Eleanor’s character would answer to him personally.
The ballroom froze. Dukes did not make public threats. Dukes did not defend compromised women. Lady Beatrice stepped forward, attempting to suggest that he had been deceived, but Alexander cut her off coldly and forbade her from speaking of Eleanor in his presence again. Beatrice retreated, humiliated and furious.