He was not a cruel man by nature. This was what made his cruelty so precise. A man who enjoyed causing pain would have been easier to navigate. His provocations would have had a pattern, a rhythm, something Phoebe could have mapped and anticipated.
But Nathaniel’s coldness came from a deeper source, the conviction that his life had been arranged without his consent, and that Phoebe, quiet, capable, unremarkable Phoebe, was the visible evidence of that arrangement. He did not raise his voice. He did not strike. He simply treated her as though she were a piece of furniture that had been delivered to the wrong room, something to be endured until it could be moved.
The banishment to the East Wing was the culmination of 6 weeks of this. There had been no specific incident, no argument at dinner, no embarrassment before guests. Phoebe had simply existed in his house with too much competence and too little drama, and Nathaniel, who had spent the day reviewing estate accounts that revealed the full extent of debts his father had concealed, had needed someone to punish who would not fight back. She did not fight back. She unpacked her trunk, which Mrs. Tull’s girl brought across within the hour, and she slept that night in a bed that smelled of lavender sachets placed there by someone who had died before Phoebe was born.
In the morning, she rose early before the household stirred and walked every room of the East Wing with her list and a stub of pencil. There were 14 rooms in total, six bedchambers of varying size, two dressing rooms, a sitting room with south-facing windows that caught the morning light beautifully, a small library that had been emptied of its books but retained its shelves, a linen closet, a still room that connected to the servants’ corridor below, and two rooms so filled with discarded furniture that she could not yet determine their original purpose. The bones of the wing were sound.
The roof did not leak. The chimneys, when she asked Cavender to send a boy to inspect them, drew cleanly. What the East Wing lacked was not structure but attention, the slow daily work of inhabitation that turns a collection of rooms into a place where life is conducted.
Phoebe began. She did not ask Nathaniel’s permission. This was not defiance.
It was simply that the question did not occur to her. He had told her to sleep in the East Wing. He had not told her to suffer there.
Within a week, she had the south-facing sitting room cleared of its stored furniture and arranged with pieces she had selected from the other rooms, a writing desk with good light, two armchairs that wanted only new cushions, a small table for tea. She asked Mrs. Tull for candles and received them without comment. She asked Cavender about the damp in the north wall, and he sent a man to repoint the exterior brickwork, adding the cost to the quarterly maintenance accounts without troubling the duke.