THE ADDRESS HE DIDN’T KNOW
The first thing Michael noticed was that Emma had brought back the wrong bag.
She had left on Friday with the faded canvas tote she took everywhere. When she came through the kitchen on Saturday morning, she was carrying a black overnight bag he hadn’t seen in years. Her wedding ring was still on. So were yesterday’s earrings. She looked exhausted, but when he asked whether she’d had a good night at Jessica’s, she said, “It was fine,” and went upstairs.
He spent the morning trying to decide which detail bothered him most. By noon, he had stopped pretending to watch television. At two, he called Jessica, making his voice casual enough to embarrass himself.
“Did Emma leave her charger there?”
“I don’t think so. I’ll check.”
“She said she stayed over.”
A pause followed. It wasn’t long, but Michael heard everything he feared inside it.
“She was here,” Jessica said carefully. “But she left before midnight. I thought she went home.”
“What time?”
“Nine or ten? I’m not sure. David came to help her with something.”
Michael thanked her for checking about the charger. Then he sat with his phone in his hand until the screen went dark.
He knew David. They had met at Jessica’s birthday dinner the previous winter, where David had spent twenty minutes talking to Emma about the neighborhood they had both grown up in. Michael remembered thinking he seemed harmless. Now he replayed the evening and couldn’t remember whether David had touched her arm.
Emma came downstairs at four, her hair still damp from a shower. She opened the refrigerator, stared into it, and closed it without taking anything.
“We should use the chicken tonight,” she said. “It’s been in there since Wednesday.”
Michael turned his phone facedown on the table.
“I asked you last night where you were.”
She stopped with her hand on the refrigerator handle.
“I told you I stayed at Jessica’s, right? Why are you asking again?”
“Because something doesn’t add up.”
“What doesn’t add up?”
“Your story.”
For a second, he thought she might tell him immediately. Instead, she pulled out the chair opposite him and sat down, leaving the whole table between them.
“I already told you what happened.”
They had been married six years. Michael was thirty-six, Emma thirty-four. They owned a small house with a leaking upstairs window and a mortgage that had recently become more expensive. Neither had cheated before, as far as the other knew. They were the couple friends called solid, which usually meant they arrived together and didn’t argue in restaurants.
They had met while waiting for delayed trains. Emma had offered him half a packet of crackers, and he had made her laugh by reading the increasingly optimistic departure announcements aloud. For the first year, they stayed up talking until neither could keep their eyes open. He knew how she took bad news. She knew when he was hungry before he did.
