“I’ve been trying,” he said.
“I know you have.”
“You don’t sound like you know.”
“Trying and hearing me aren’t always the same thing.”
Emma pulled the loose thread until it broke. She looked startled by it, then folded the tiny piece into her palm.
“Last month I said I couldn’t keep being the person who remembers everything. You told me to make a list.”
“So I’d know what needed doing.”
“I work all day too, Michael. Then I come home and figure out what you need to know so you can help me with our life. I don’t want another job assigning you jobs.”
“You could have said it like that.”
“I did. You said I’d been watching too many videos about mental load.”
He remembered saying it. He remembered smiling, expecting her to smile back.
“That was a stupid thing to say.”
“Yes. It was.”
The kitchen clock ticked above the door. Outside, someone started a lawn mower. Their neighbor was having an ordinary Saturday, and Michael resented him for it.
“And that means you secretly rent an apartment?”
“No.”
“Because you keep explaining everything I did.”
Emma looked down at the key.
“You’re right.”
He hadn’t expected that. Neither of them spoke for a few seconds.
“Being unhappy doesn’t make what I did honest,” she said. “Jessica wasn’t confused. David wasn’t a group of friends. I said those things because I didn’t want to say I’d already made a decision without you.”
“You let me think you were having an affair.”
“I didn’t know that’s what you thought when I came home. But once you started asking, I knew. And I still kept dodging. I’m sorry.”
Michael rubbed his eyes. The relief that she hadn’t slept with David was there, unwanted and insufficient. It didn’t make the apartment disappear. It didn’t give him back the weeks in which she had been preparing a different life while he complained that she kept going quiet.
“How long?”
“I’ve been looking for three weeks.”
He had helped her replace a windshield wiper three weeks ago. She had kissed his cheek in the driveway and reminded him to take his lunch from the refrigerator. He tried to fit that woman beside the one searching rental listings.
“How could you act normal?”
“Sometimes normal was just easier. Sometimes I thought I’d change my mind.”
“Did you?”
She breathed in slowly.
“A lot.”
Michael stood and went to the sink. There were two mugs in it and a plate with dried egg around the edge. His plate, from breakfast. He washed it because he didn’t know what to do with his hands, then stopped when he realized how it might look.
“I’m not doing this to prove a point.”