—

The first movement was almost delicate. Beatrice scooped the crushed pear with the edge of her spoon and tipped it onto Clara’s gown. The fruit slid down the silk, leaving a sticky stain. Clara jerked back, but her aunt caught the fabric and brushed it with her napkin, spreading the mark wider. “There,” Beatrice said. “Now everyone can see that even your dress has given up waiting for a husband.”

The room went still. A young guest gave a nervous laugh and then stopped when no one joined her. Clara’s face burned. She pressed her napkin against the stain, trying not to let the tears fall. “A woman of twenty-eight should understand her position,” Beatrice continued. “You have no husband, no children, and no prospects. You are fortunate that I continue to provide a place for you.”

Clara’s voice was quiet. “I have never asked you to provide more than my father’s will allows.”

Beatrice’s eyes sharpened. For one brief moment, the mask slipped. Then she leaned back and laughed as though Clara had made a joke. “Your father’s will? My dear, you would be lost without me.”

The words were meant to finish the humiliation. They did not. Something in Clara’s expression had changed. She looked at her aunt steadily, not with anger but with a clarity Beatrice had not seen before. At the far end of the table, a chair moved. Julian rose. He did not raise his voice. He did not look at Beatrice first. His gaze rested on Clara, and the entire room followed it. “Lady Clara Whitmore,” he said, “I believe this evening has gone on long enough without anyone remembering who deserves respect.”

Beatrice opened her mouth, but the duke continued. She wished to vanish, then remembered the people who trusted her to speak.

—

“I have listened to this table speak of Lady Clara as though her life were a failed arrangement,” Julian said. “I have heard her patience mistaken for weakness and her kindness described as idleness. I will not pretend I find any of it amusing.”

Beatrice lifted her chin. “Your Grace, this is a family matter.”

“Then it is fortunate that I am addressing Lady Clara, not you.”

A murmur passed among the guests. Clara stood halfway from her chair, uncertain whether to leave or remain. Julian stepped away from his place and walked the length of the table. The servants moved aside. No one tried to stop him. He paused beside Clara. The stain on her gown was plain beneath the candlelight. He did not touch it or pretend not to see it. Instead, he offered his hand. “I have waited a long time for the chance to ask you something properly,” he said. “If you will allow me, I should like to speak with you—not as a duke making an offer, but as the man who has never forgotten you.”