Clara looked at his hand. She remembered the letters from Dover and Brussels, the quiet walks, and the way he had listened when she spoke about the village. She also remembered being told that he had chosen someone else. Beatrice rose so abruptly that her chair struck the wall. “Your Grace, you cannot be serious.”

Julian did not turn. “I have never been more serious.”

The room seemed to hold its breath. Clara’s eyes lifted from his offered hand to his face. For the first time that evening, she allowed herself to hope that the story she had been told about his silence might not be true. She had not yet answered him. He would not leave her alone.

—

The guests remained motionless, unsure whether they were witnessing a proposal, a quarrel, or the beginning of a scandal that would occupy every drawing room in Bath by morning. Lady Hensley lowered her glass. The retired colonel studied the tablecloth. Henry Vane looked from his mother to the duke and seemed to understand that the evening had slipped beyond anyone’s control. Beatrice recovered first. “Lady Clara is overwhelmed. She has been made the subject of an unfortunate scene. It would be ungentlemanly to press her now.”

Julian finally looked at her. “I have not asked for an answer tonight. I have asked whether she will hear me. There is a difference.”

Clara’s fingers hovered above his hand. She could feel the room waiting for her to accept or refuse, as though her future were another course to be served. She wanted to tell them all that she was not a prize, not a settlement, and not a remedy for the duke’s loneliness. Instead, she looked at Julian and saw the same restraint she remembered. He had given her a choice before. He was giving her one now. “Your Grace,” she began. Her aunt stepped closer. “Clara, do not embarrass yourself further.”

Julian’s hand remained steady. “Lady Clara may speak for herself.”

For the first time in years, someone had said those words in front of Beatrice and meant them. Clara took a breath. The tears still shone in her eyes, but they were no longer only tears of shame. She looked at the duke with surprise, caution, and a hope she had not permitted herself to feel in a very long time. Her answer had not yet come. The duke’s patience made the offer more difficult to dismiss, because he was not asking her to trade one guardian for another.

—

The duke’s sister, Margaret, had arrived with the party but had remained in the drawing room because the dinner conversation bored her. When she heard the sudden silence, she entered the dining room and saw Clara standing beside Julian. She recognized her immediately. “Clara?” Margaret said. “Is that really you?”