Then a number I didn’t recognize lit up my screen. The area code was from Alabama. For a second, I considered letting it go to voicemail. But I answered. A woman spoke before I could say anything.
“Is this Eliza’s husband?”
I knew immediately it was Leah.
“Yes,” I said.
Her breath caught, as if she had been preparing herself to make this call for a long time.
“Good,” Leah said quietly. “Before you drive out here, you need to understand what Sunday was really supposed to be.”
I looked down at Marcus’s photo again. That was when I saw the detail I had missed the first time. Leah wasn’t watching Grant. She wasn’t looking at the locked gate, either. Her eyes were fixed on the cabin itself. And in her right hand, held low beside her leg, was a key I had never given her.
Leah didn’t sound frightened when she spoke. That was worse somehow. Her voice was steady, measured, like she had already spent the morning making decisions no one else had been prepared to make.
“Don’t come charging up here,” she said. “Grant is angry, Eliza is hiding something, and Marcus is the only reason this hasn’t turned into a disaster.”
I gripped the edge of the kitchen counter.
“What is that key?”
For a moment, all I heard was wind moving across the phone. Then Leah said, “It opens a door on your property. Just not the door you think.”
My eyes went back to the photo. The key looked old, dull brass with a square black plastic tag hanging from the ring. I zoomed in until the image blurred across my screen. There were white letters on the tag.
H-17.
“I’ve never seen that key,” I said.
“I know,” Leah replied. “That’s why I came.”
Chapter 3
She told me she had found it two nights earlier in the lining of Grant’s truck console. It had been tucked behind the registration papers, wrapped in a strip of blue painter’s tape. At first, she assumed it belonged to one of his construction jobs. Grant did renovation work all over the county. He was always carrying strange keys, measuring tapes, access cards, and receipts that meant nothing to anyone but him.
But then she found a folded printout beneath it. It was a map of my cabin property. Not a general map from the internet. Not directions to the gate. A hand-drawn sketch.
Leah said it showed the cabin, the tool shed, the old fire pit behind the trees, and a narrow line leading toward the hill behind the garage. Someone had circled one spot in red ink and written two words beside it.
SERVICE ROOM.
“There is no service room,” I told her.
“That’s what I thought too,” Leah said. “Then I called Marcus.”
My stomach dropped. Marcus had never mentioned a service room to me. I had owned that cabin for nearly nine years. I knew the screened porch, the fireplace, the attic crawlspace with the broken insulation, every warped floorboard in the back hallway. But Marcus had been there longer than I had.