“Those pictures show the scene before I went in,” he said. “There was only one cabinet inside when I opened that room. But the marks outside show something else was carried away.”

The deputy asked, “Who had access to the cabin before you changed the code?”

“Only me and Marcus,” I said.

Marcus shook his head.

“Not exactly.”

Everyone looked at him. He rubbed one hand over his jaw.

“A few months back, Eliza called me and said Damon wanted a contractor to inspect the garage foundation. She said it was a surprise repair, something Damon didn’t want to worry about. She knew enough details about the property that I believed her.”

My stomach dropped.

“You let someone onto the property?” I asked.

Marcus’s eyes met mine.

“Once. A man in a white work van. He said he was with Grant’s crew.”

Grant’s head snapped up.

“That wasn’t my crew.”

Marcus turned toward him.

“Maybe not. But somebody used your name.”

That was the first crack in Eliza’s story that she could not talk her way around. She folded her arms, but her posture had changed. Her shoulders were rigid now. Her eyes flicked toward the woods behind the cabin again. Deputy Harris noticed it too.

“Mrs. Nash,” he said, “did you bring anyone else here today?”

“No.”

“Did anyone leave the property before we arrived?”

“No.”

He held her gaze.

“Are you sure?”

Eliza pressed her lips together. Leah slowly pulled one more item from her purse. It was a printed hotel receipt, folded at the corners.

“There’s one name you haven’t asked about,” she said.

Eliza’s eyes locked on it.

Grant whispered, “Leah, stop.”

But Leah did not look at him.

“The receipt was for a room near the interstate. Two nights ago. Grant was there, but he wasn’t alone. The reservation was under the name of a man named Owen Price.”

Deputy Harris took the receipt. I had never heard the name, but Eliza had. Her face went completely still. Marcus looked at her.

“That the guy who came in the white van?”

Eliza said nothing. The deputy reached for his radio.

“Dispatch, can you run a name for me? Owen Price. Possible connection to an ongoing property matter.”

Eliza finally found her voice.

“You are all making a mistake.”

“No,” Leah said. “You made the mistake of thinking everyone else would protect you.”

The words landed harder than any scream could have. Deputy Harris moved a few steps away to speak into his radio. Grant walked toward Eliza, but Leah stepped between them before he reached her.

“You don’t get to coach her now,” Leah said.

“I’m not coaching anybody.”

“Then stand there and tell the truth for once.”

Grant looked toward the deputy, then toward the cabin, then down at his own hands. The anger drained out of him, leaving something smaller underneath.

“He said it was just documents,” Grant muttered.

Eliza turned on him.

“Grant.”

Chapter 8

“He said they were records from a business dispute,” Grant continued, louder now. “Eliza told me Damon had hidden them here and that if they came out, he’d lose everything.”