And then at last, she sat down and cried.
For 3 days, Etta stayed in the cottage. She dug the garden. She fed the hens. She did not go near the hall. But the village talked, and the talk came to her anyway.
On the first day, the Duke sent to Exeter for a new housekeeper. On the second day, the new housekeeper arrived. She was a tall woman named Mrs. Gage, and she lost the key to the wine cellar before dinner. On the third day, the laundry maid quit. The cook burned the bread, and two of the footmen had a fight in the hall about whose turn it was to fill the lamps.
“They say the Duke had cold soup and no candles last night,” said her grandmother with a small smile. “They say he sat in the dark.”
“Good,” said Etta.
But she did not feel good. She lay awake that night and thought about old Mr. Bright, who still lived in the little steward’s cottage by the hall gate. She had read his letters to him every Sunday. Who would read to him now? And she thought about Mr. Pell and his clean pink hands.
On the fourth morning, there was a knock at the door. Etta opened it. The Duke of Ulshold was standing on the step.
He had to bend his head under the low roof. He was not wearing his good coat. His boots were muddy as if he had walked.
“Mrs. Dale,” he said.
“Your Grace.”
She did not move out of the doorway.
“I have hired three housekeepers in four days,” he said. “One cried, one left in the night, the third one is still trying to find the kitchen.”
He paused.
“I said a stupid thing. I came to say so.”
Etta looked at him. He did not look like a duke this morning. He looked like a tired man who had slept badly.
“You threw my book on the floor,” she said.
“Yes.”
“In front of the girls I trained.”
“Yes.”
His jaw tightened.
“I am not good at saying sorry, Mrs. Dale. I was a soldier too long, but I am trying.”
“Why did you believe him?” she asked. “Mr. Pell, why did you believe him and not me?”
The Duke was quiet for a moment.
“Because he showed me numbers,” he said. “And numbers do not lie. That is what I thought.”
“Numbers do not lie,” said Etta, “but men who write them do.”
He looked at her sharply.
“What do you mean?”
Etta stepped back and let him in. Her grandmother stood up, dropped a quick curtsy, and went out to the hens with her eyes very wide. Etta went to the shelf by the fire. She took down a thin brown book tied with string.
“When Mr. Bright went blind, I did his work at night,” she said. “I kept the rents. I kept the house money. Everything went into the big books at the hall, but I always made a small copy for myself here in case anything was lost. Mr. Bright taught me that.”