“How do you know about my book?”

“The Duke left it on his desk. It is in the fire now.”

He smiled.

“Tomorrow the magistrate will come. A housekeeper who steals silver will go to Exeter jail and perhaps across the sea to Australia. And who will believe the word of a thief about the rents?”

Then he walked away and the lamp went with him and Etta was alone in the dark.

She sat on the cold bench all night. She thought of the little brown book burning. She thought of her grandmother alone in the cottage.

She thought of the ship and the long sea and never seeing the river again. She had walked away from the hall with her head high. Now she would leave Devon with her hands tied.

The magistrate came at noon. He was old Sir Henry Fowler and he held the hearing in the big tithe barn because it was rent day and half the county was there already. The farmers had come with their money for Mr. Pell. Their wives and children had come to see the fun.

Now they all crowded in to see the housekeeper who stole the Duke’s silver. Etta stood in front of Sir Henry with her hands still tied. Mr. Pell stood beside the table with the six candlesticks in a row.

“It is very simple, Sir Henry,” he said in his soft voice. “She had the keys. The silver was found at her home. My men saw it. I am only sorry it was someone we all trusted.”

“Mrs. Dale,” said Sir Henry, “what do you say?”

“I did not take it,” said Etta.

Her voice shook, but she kept it loud.

“Mr. Pell put it there because I know he has been stealing the rents.”

There was a murmur. Mr. Pell gave a sad little laugh.

“You see,” he said, “now she makes wild stories. Where is her proof?”

Etta opened her mouth. She had no proof. The book was ashes.

Then the big barn doors banged open. The Duke of Ulshold came in still in his riding coat with mud to his knees. Behind him came a thin man in black with a leather case and behind him came old Mr. Bright, the blind steward, holding the arm of a stable boy.

“Her proof,” said the Duke, “is here.”

The whole barn turned.

“Sir Henry,” said the Duke, “my steward says he burned a little brown book from my desk. He did, but he burned the wrong one. I am not a fool twice. I took Mrs. Dale’s book with me to Exeter and I left an old book of army songs on my desk in its place.”

Mr. Pell’s pink face went white. The Duke took the brown book from his coat and held it up. Then he turned to the farmers.

“Hext,” he said, “what do you pay me each quarter?”

A big red-faced farmer pulled off his hat.

“£20, Your Grace, always have.”