It was not a standard arrangement. It was the arrangement of a woman who had not trusted the outcome and he had not asked why. Because he had not asked anything about Eleanor Vance. Had not asked because asking would have implied he did not already know everything he needed to know. Which was the particular arrogance of a man who had been told he was intelligent so often and from such an early age that he had confused intelligence with understanding.
On the third day, he had gone to his desk not to find anything, to sit with the knowledge of what was in it. The third drawer. He had known the letter was there. He had put it there himself four years ago when he found it in his father’s papers after the old duke died. His father had opened it, read it, and kept it.
He himself had read it and had put it away. He had told himself in the language of a man who had been educated in justifications that it was a historical document, that his father had acted, that he himself had done nothing, that he was not responsible for the architecture his father had built before he was old enough to influence it. He had told himself this so persuasively that he had almost stopped noticing the third drawer, almost, not quite. Because when the Vance marriage had been proposed by his mother as a sensible resolution to a family entanglement he had inherited without choosing, he had known, in the third drawer part of his mind, exactly who Eleanor Vance was and what she had tried to do.
And he had agreed to the marriage anyway. And he had not told Isabel. And he had not told himself clearly why. Because some things, if stated clearly, do not survive the stating.
He was admitted to Philippa Vance’s house by a housekeeper whose expression indicated that she had received instructions about his arrival and that those instructions were not warm. He waited in the front sitting room among Philippa’s comfortable and deliberately unfashionable furniture and her collection of books arranged by subject rather than by height which he noticed because it was the kind of detail you noticed when you were trying to compose yourself before a conversation you did not know how to begin.
Philippa herself received him first. She stood in the doorway of the sitting room and looked at him with the expression of a woman who had already judged the case and was withholding the sentence as a courtesy to the defendant.
“She will see you,” Philippa said, “because she has decided to, not because I have advised it.”
She paused.
“I want you to understand the difference.”
“I understand it.”
Philippa held his gaze for a moment longer than was comfortable, then stepped aside.
Isabel came in after a few minutes, still in dark wool, not mourning black but the considered shade of a woman who had decided that the occasion did not call for color. She did not sit. She stood by the window in the gray December light and looked at him with the expression of a woman who has already held the most difficult part of a conversation in her own mind alone many times and knows every possible version of how it ends.