“You knew,” she said, not as an accusation, as the first fact established so they could proceed to the rest.
“Yes,” he said.
She had not expected him to agree without negotiation. The directness of it stopped her for a moment and he saw it stop her, and he did not use the moment, which was the first thing he had done correctly in the entire history of their acquaintance.
“Your father arranged it?” she said.
“The withdrawal?”
“Yes. And when your father died and you found my mother’s letter, you understood what it meant.”
“I understood what it meant.”
“And then you agreed to marry me?”
“Yes.”
She turned to the window. He could see her reflection in the glass, pale and composed, and he could see in that reflection the effort the composure was costing her, which was the second thing he had ever seen in her that was real, the first being the moment at the altar when she had set the ring on the bishop’s Bible with the steadiness of a woman who was not steady at all, but had decided that steadiness was the only thing she had left to offer.
“I want to understand why,” she said.
He thought about the various answers he had prepared. He discarded all of them.
“I thought I could make it right without telling you. I thought I could manage the consequences quietly, restore what my father had taken, and you would never need to know what the marriage had been arranged around.”
“You thought you could resolve my mother’s grievance without consulting the person she had the grievance for?”
When she said it in that order, it sounded exactly as wrong as it was.
“Yes.”
“She spent herself down to nothing,” Isabel said, and her voice for the first time was not controlled, not a little, not around the word nothing. “She wrote to your father, and then your father destroyed what remained of our finances, and she died knowing it had made things worse, knowing she had tried and it had cost, and it had not been enough. And you found her letter and you thought the appropriate response was to manage it.”
He said nothing. There was nothing to say that was not a diminishment of what she had just said.
“She never begged,” Isabel said, “not once in her life. She found the evidence and she went directly to the source and she made her terms clear and she signed her name, her full name, because she was not ashamed of what she was doing and it destroyed her.”
“It did not kill her. It wore her out,” Isabel said, turning from the window. “A woman who was never worn out by anything. She spent herself and then she died and you kept her letter in a drawer and then you agreed to marry her daughter and you told yourself this was resolution.”
She looked at him steadily.
“I am not interested in being resolved, Your Grace.”