She heard his step behind her and turned. He had taken off his coat. His cravat was loosened. He looked, in the firelight, not like a duke at all, but like a man who had been carrying something very heavy for a very long time and had only just set it down.

“This was hers,” he said, nodding at the pianoforte. “My father wanted it broken up for firewood. Mrs. Bell and the old butler hid it in here and told him it had been done. I’ve known for years. I could never bring myself to open that door.”

“It’s beautiful,” Anna said.

He came to stand beside her. For a long time, neither of them spoke.

“I owe your father a debt I can never repay,” he said at last. “And I owe you more. You gave me back my mother tonight, Miss Hartwell. And you gave me back my daughter.”

His voice roughened.

“She called me papa. She has not said my name since Caroline died. I thought I would never hear it again as long as I lived.”

“Philippa did that herself, Your Grace. I only hummed.”

“You hummed,” he said. “In a house where it was forbidden. You taught music to a child who could not speak with nothing but a pencil and a sheet of paper. You stood up in church for my daughter when I was not there to do it. And tonight you sat at that pianoforte with 20 people laughing at you and played my mother’s song anyway.”

He turned to face her.

“Why?”

Anna looked down at her hands.

“Because my father asked me to bring it home. And because…”

She stopped.

“Because…”

She lifted her eyes to his.

“Because you were sitting all alone by the window, Your Grace. And you looked like a man who had been waiting a very long time for someone to play him something kind.”

He drew a sharp breath.

“Anna,” he said.

It was the first time he had ever spoken her Christian name. In his low voice, it sounded like the third note of the lullaby, unexpected and impossibly right.

“I have been a coward for a very long time,” he said. “I hid from music because it reminded me of the one person in my childhood who loved me. Then I hid from my own child because I did not know how to love her the way my mother loved me. And these past 2 weeks while my aunt paraded Lady Cecily before me like a horse at Tattersalls, I hid from you. Because I knew that if I sat by that library fire with you one more evening I would never want to sit by it with anyone else.”

Anna’s heart was beating so hard she could scarcely breathe.

“Your Grace…”

“Gideon.”

“Gideon, you cannot. I am a governess, a music master’s daughter. I have nothing. People will say…”

“People,” said the Duke of Ellsworth, “looked at you tonight. 20 of them. And then they watched you give a silent child back her voice and watched you return a dead woman’s love to her son and not one of them was laughing by the end.”

He took both her hands in his.

“My father spent his whole life caring what people would say. It made him cruel. It broke my mother’s heart. And it very nearly made me into a man exactly like him. I will not make his mistakes, Anna. I would far rather make my own. And your father, by every account I have heard tonight was a finer gentleman than mine ever was.”