Philippa had found five robins and a sparrow that she insisted, with great seriousness and a stamp of her small boot, was also a robin. Anna had laughed and given her the almond anyway, and Philippa had smiled, a real smile, wide and gap-toothed and dazzling. When Anna turned, the Duke was standing at the end of the gravel path. He was in his riding coat, his boots splashed with mud, his hat in his hand. He was not looking at Anna.

He was looking at his daughter, and his face wore the expression of a man who has been lost in the dark for a very long time and has suddenly glimpsed a lamp in a window. Then Philippa saw him and the smile vanished. She stepped behind Anna’s skirts. The Duke’s face closed like a door.

“Miss Hartwell,” he said curtly. “A word when Lady Philippa is at her supper.”

Anna went to the library at 6:00 with her heart in her throat, certain she was about to be dismissed. She had broken no rule, not out loud, but she knew how quickly a governess could be sent away for nothing at all. The Duke stood at the fire with his back to her.

“She smiled,” he said, without turning.

Anna hesitated.

“Yes, Your Grace.”

“She has not smiled at me in two years. She has not smiled at anyone.”

He turned. In the firelight, his face looked older and very tired.

“What did you do?”

“I gave her almonds for robins,” said Anna. “And for one sparrow.”

For a moment, he simply stared at her, and then astonishingly, the corner of his mouth moved. It was not a smile, not quite. But it was the ghost of one.

“A sparrow?”

“She was very firm that it was a robin, Your Grace. I did not feel equal to arguing.”

He let out a breath that was almost a laugh. Then he gestured to the chair opposite the fire.

“Sit down, Miss Hartwell.”

She sat. They talked for nearly an hour about Philippa, what she ate, how she slept, what frightened her, what made her curious. Anna told him about the robins and the reading. And the way Philippa traced letters with her fingertip on the frosted nursery window. She did not tell him about the paper pianoforte. She did not tell him about the humming.

And the duke told her, in short, halting sentences, as though each one cost him something, about his wife. The Duchess Caroline had died of a fever in the spring two years ago, very quickly. Philippa had been in the room. After that, the child had stopped speaking. And the duke, who had never known how to speak to her even before, had stopped trying.

“I am not,” he said, staring into the flames, “a man who knows how to comfort a child. I was not raised to it. My father believed that tenderness made a man weak. He was very thorough in his beliefs.”

His jaw tightened.

“I find I am more his son than I would wish.”

Anna looked at him for a long moment.

“Forgive me, Your Grace. But a man who was truly his father’s son would not have stood at the end of that garden path looking at his daughter the way you did this afternoon.”

He turned his head sharply. Their eyes met. And something shifted in the room. Something small and quiet and impossible to name.

The fire popped and settled. Neither of them looked away. Then the Duke rose abruptly.

“Thank you, Miss Hartwell. That will be all.”