Mrs. Pargeter and Miss Rexham left within the quarter hour. By evening, half of Hampshire knew the duke’s new housekeeper could count. By Sunday, the other half knew it as well.
“His Grace has walked past the library nine times today,” said Mrs. Culpepper, setting down the tray. “He has not once gone in.”
“He is a busy man,” said Philippa.
“He is a man with one dog and no engagements,” said Mrs. Culpepper. “I counted.”
“It seemed the right house for it.”
She began on the ledgers that night by a whole candle. The estate book was a foot thick, bound in calf, and kept in a hand that grew careful whenever the sums grew large. She worked until 2:00, slept 4 hours, and began again.
By the ninth night, she had the roof. 12 entries, one to each quarter, across 3 years. Slating, west range. £34 7 shillings and 4 pence every time, to the penny.
Real repairs are never the same twice. She multiplied it, and multiplied it again, and then a third time on the back of an envelope, in case her pen was lying. £412, 8 shillings.
She took Mrs. Culpepper up the west stair at dawn with a lantern and a measuring tape. They counted the missing slates from the leads. They stopped at 281.
“Three years I’ve told His Grace that roof was open to the sky,” said Mrs. Culpepper.
“And what did he say?”
“That Mr. Pettigrew had slated it at the March quarter.”
“Mr. Pettigrew has been paid to slate it 12 times,” said Philippa. “He has slated it never.”
Mrs. Culpepper looked at her for a long moment.
“Well,” she said, “that wants saying out loud.”
She said it out loud to the cook, the butler, and the dog before noon.
The Duke received her in the study at 6:00. The study smelled of ink, cold hearth, and a long habit of silence. She laid the page on his desk. She laid the envelope beside it.
“£412, 8 shillings,” she said. “Taken from your estate in 3 years by Mr. Pettigrew under the head of slating. The roof has not been touched. Mrs. Culpepper and I counted 281 slates gone. I have the figures to the penny. You will wish to dismiss him.”
The Duke looked at the page for a long time. He did not look surprised. He looked like a man who has heard a clock strike that he had been dreading for years.
“Thank you,” he said.
“You are not surprised,” said Philippa.
“I am never surprised by arithmetic,” said the Duke. “Mr. Pettigrew will stay.”
“Stay?”
“For the present.”
“He will repay it.”
Philippa kept her face still. She had lived in a house that rationed its candles while its servants grew fat, and she knew the shape of a master who would not look. A man too idle or too stingy to discharge a thief. She entered it under his name in pencil.
There was one more column she could not make sense of. 11 names paid on the quarter day from the Duke’s private account, entered under sundries with no goods against them. £400 a quarter in all, back as far as the books went. A Duke who paid 11 people in secret was keeping something or someone or several.
She wrote the possibilities in pencil, too. She did not like any of them. She had agreed not to ask. She did not ask.
At midnight, the Duke of Kestrelmere stood in the doorway of the library and did not go in. Through the gap, he could see her bent over the second volume with her sleeves pushed back, biting the end of a pen. A whole candle burned at her elbow. He had put it there himself that afternoon and told Mrs. Culpepper to say it was the housekeeper’s doing.