In 9 days, she had found the roof. He had spent 15 years making certain no one could read the third column. She would reach it by Martinmas. He knew it as he knew his own pulse. He ought to send her off in the morning with a character and a quarter’s wages. He had sent off three bookkeepers before her, and every one had been cheaper than this one.

He did not want to send her off. That was the whole difficulty, and it frightened him more than the thief did. She had counted 281 slates in the rain. She had looked at his face while she did it, and had not once asked it to be kinder. No one had looked at him like that since he was 19. Brigadier pressed against his leg, a warm weight, a reproach.

“I know,” said the duke to the dog. “I know.”

He left the door open. He went up the stair without the lamp because the lamp cost money, and the money was already spoken for.

Four weeks after the inn, a letter came for Philippa by the Winchester post. The postage had been paid. She noted that first from habit. Mr. Fenwick, solicitor of Gracechurch Street, had been her father’s man of business. She had written to him on the 6th of October asking for a plain statement of her father’s estate. She had written in a temper over a cold grate 6 days before Lady Sutherby put her trunk in the road.

She read his answer standing at the study window. She read it twice. Then she sat down in the duke’s second-best chair without being asked.

“Bad news?” said the duke from the desk.

“My father left 9,000 pounds in the 3%,” said Philippa. “270 pounds a year paid to the trustee. Sir Aldous Sutherby, trustee. I was allowed 48.”

“48?” said the duke.

“Of 270. 222 pounds a year for 6 years. 1,332 pounds. I was told the estate was encumbered. It was not encumbered. It was spent.”

She turned the letter over and read the date again.

“I wrote to Mr. Fenwick on the 6th,” she said. “He wrote to Sir Aldous on the 9th asking for the trust accounts. On the 12th, I was informed that I was not required.”

She stopped. The room had gone quiet.

For a month she had told herself she had been thrown out because she was poor and plain and in the way. She turned the whole afternoon over as one turns a coin and read the other face. The trunk in the puddle. The audience. The speed of it. It had been staged in a day by a woman who had been given a day’s notice.

“She did not throw out a poor relation,” said Philippa. “She threw out a creditor.”

Before the creditor could speak.

“You are not required,” she said in Lady Sutherby’s voice.

It was not contempt. It was fear. The Duke put down his pen.

“I wondered,” he said, “when you would count your own.”

“You knew?”

“I suspected. Nobody audits a baronet. I would not have said it unasked.”

“I’m going to Winchester in the morning,” said Philippa. “Mr. Fenwick will want my signature and I will want a court. But I have worked in this house a month and I will have one answer first. I will not keep books I do not understand. Who are the 11?”

The truth, when it came, came quietly. The Duke rose from the desk. He crossed to the iron chest under the window. He did not open it. He laid both hands flat on the lid.

“My father forged his friends’ names, Miss Corbold. 11 friends. I found the notes the week I’d buried him. I did not take them to the magistrate. I did not tell my mother. I did not tell the county. I told no living person until this minute because I was 19 and the shame was mine to carry. I sold the horses. I sold the plate. I let the roofs go and I let Hampshire call me a miser because every quarter day 400 pounds goes out of this house to 11 families and the roofs come second. 26,000 pounds was forged in his hand. I have paid 25,600. You may go to Winchester tomorrow. You may go to Lady Sutherby tonight and to the Gazette and tell them what you like. You may leave in my own carriage with your wages to the quarter and my letter. I shall think no worse of you. Nothing in our terms is withdrawn. Nothing.”