He had four bays and a chestnut, and the four bays were as good a match as anything in the field. He had a paper for the second of them, a bay mare of five. It was written out and signed by a veterinary man at Derby. Sound in wind, limb, and eye.

“There’s the certificate,” said Mr. Kidd. “And there’s the mare, and there’s my name, which has been in this trade since before you were breeched, Your Grace, begging your pardon.”

The Duke looked at the mare and then at Catherine. Catherine went to the mare’s head and stood at her shoulder. She looked at the eye and the nostril and the way the flank moved when the animal breathed out, which is the part nobody watches. She put her hand flat on the windpipe.

“Trot her up,” she said.

The boy trotted her up.

“Now gallop her,” said Catherine, “up the field, past the tents, and turn her short at the top, and bring her back fast.”

“I’ll not have my mare galloped in a fair field by a girl,” said Mr. Kidd.

There it was. The circle that had gathered went very quiet in the way that a crowd goes quiet when it has been given something good.

“She has had a ball of physic this morning and a long steady hour on the road behind it,” said Catherine, “which will hold her for the day. She is a whistler, not far gone. She will pass here. She will pass at Ashbourne. She will be roaring by the middle of December, and the man who buys her will think he has ruined her himself. He will never say a word about it because a man does not like to be told he cannot hear.”

“There is a certificate,” said Kidd.

“Yes,” said Catherine. “I do not doubt the certificate. She would have passed it. He saw her standing in a box on a cold morning. She is a good, honest mare, and she is worth 60 guineas. You are asking 120 for her because she matches.”

“And who are you?”

That question went across the field like a struck match. Catherine opened her mouth and found there was nothing to say to it that would not sound like an apology and shut it again. Then the Duke said:

“Give me your book, Mr. Kidd.”

“My book?”

“Your sale book? You have it in your coat. Every man here knows you have it in your coat.”

Kidd gave it up. The Duke laid it open on the tail of the cart and took the pencil out of the strap. He wrote in it standing in front of 30 or 40 men in the middle of the fair in a hand that half of them could read upside down. He read it out while he wrote it because he wanted no argument afterwards about what it said.

“The bay mare, 5 years, refused this day on the judgment of Miss Catherine Stanbridge that she is a whistler and drugged for the fair. Miss Stanbridge’s judgment is taken here before any certificate. Rockholm.”

And he signed it underneath her name. Nobody said anything at all for about 4 seconds. Then Mr. Kidd said in a voice that had gone quite thin:

“That’ll follow that mare all over England. That will.”

“Yes,” said the Duke. “It will follow me too. If she is sound at Christmas, I shall be a laughing stock from here to Newmarket, and every man in this field will have the telling of it. And I should not blame them.”

They bought three horses off another man and went home at 4:00. At the turn above Bottom House, with the moor going brown and gold in front of them as far as anybody could see. She made him stop the gig.