He did not ride by the stream anymore, either. Mary Beth went down every afternoon all the same, with an apple in her pocket for his horse. Every evening, she brought it home again, and Sarah stopped arguing. It was Thomas Lamb who noticed it first. He made a remark at dinner one evening, a foolish remark about a book, the kind of remark his eldest daughter had been pouncing on since she was 12 years old.
He waited for her to pounce. She only said, “Yes, Papa.” And went on with her soup. He looked at her for a long time after that, and said nothing.
It was 5 weeks before her sisters came to her. They came together late one evening, when the house was quiet, and knocked on her bedroom door, and did not wait to be asked in. Caroline sat on the end of the bed. Augusta stood with her back against the door, as though she meant to stop anyone escaping. “Something is wrong with you.” said Augusta.
“And we want to know what it is.” “Nothing is wrong with me. You have not argued with Mama in five weeks,” said Caroline. “Not once. Mama told you yesterday that your hair looked like a bird’s nest, and you thanked her.” Sarah looked down at her hands. “Perhaps I am tired of arguing.
You have never been tired of arguing in your life.” Augusta folded her arms. “It was him, was it not, Mr. Fenwick? Something happened under that tree.” “Nothing happened. He asked, and I refused, and he went home. That is all.” “That is not all.” Caroline’s voice was quieter than usual.
“We heard you that day, Sarah, through the door. You never cry, not when Mr. Pallid asked you, nor Mr. Jessup, nor that dreadful curate with the hands. You sent every one of them home and came down to supper laughing.” She hesitated. “So, he must have said something. Something cruel.” “He did not.” “He must have,” said Augusta.
“Nothing else would make you cry like that. And I will tell you something, Sarah Lamb. We may tease you, and Caroline may say stupid things she does not mean.” “I am sorry about that,” said Caroline to her lap. “I have said so. I will say it again, but we are the only ones in this world who are allowed to vex you.
Not him, not anybody.” Augusta’s chin had come up, exactly the way Sarah’s did. “I do not care if he owns half of England. If he has wounded our sister, then he is a dreadful man, and I’m glad he never asked either of us to dance.” Sarah stared at her, and for the first time in five weeks, something like a laugh came up in her throat. “Augusta, you spent a whole afternoon changing your gown for him. Well, I have changed my mind.” Augusta sniffed.
“His friend is a far better man in any case, Mr. Grantham. He has been staying at the big house while Mr. Fenwick is away, and he has called here twice.” She colored a little. “He has asked whether he may call again on Thursday, on me.” “Augusta, and nobody is calling on me at all,” said Caroline gloomily. “So, you see, Sarah, you need not worry about either of us. We have quite given Mr. Fenwick up.
You may hate him as much as you like.” They kissed her good night, one on each cheek, and Augusta paused at the door. “Whatever he said to you,” she said, “he will answer for it one day.” When they had gone, Sarah sat on the edge of her bed in the candlelight and pressed both hands over her face. He had not said anything dreadful at all. That was the whole trouble.
A week later, Marigold Rider came over the snow-rimmed fields on a gray afternoon with her bonnet strings flying in the biting wind. Betty sent her straight upstairs, and she found Sarah sitting by her bedroom window with her mending, and shut the door firmly behind her. She stood and looked at her friend for a moment. “Good heavens, Sarah, what is happening in this house? Has your family stopped feeding you?
You look as pale as a boiled pudding.” “Thank you, Marigold. How kind.” “I am not being kind. I am being truthful.” Marigold pulled up the little chair from the dressing table and sat down right in front of her. “And I have news. He is home.” Sarah’s needle went straight into her finger.
She put the finger in her mouth and said, “Around it. Who is home? Do not pretend with me, Sarah Lamb.” “Mr. Fenwick. He came back last night. Our cowman saw his carriage on the lane after dark.” Marigold took the mending out of Sarah’s lap and set it on the bed.
“And now you are going to talk to me. There is nothing to talk about.” “That is what you said 3 weeks ago, and 2 weeks before that.” Marigold folded her hands. “I have asked you and asked you, and every time you have changed the subject or told me you were tired or found something terribly urgent to do in the kitchen. So, I stopped asking. I thought you would come to me when you were ready.” She leaned forward.
“But I have watched you every Sunday, Sarah. Every single time the church door opens, you look around as if you were expecting someone to walk in, and every time it is only old Mr. Bassett with his stick, and you turn back to your prayer book looking like that.” She pointed at Sarah’s face. “Exactly like that. I will not sit beside you and watch you suffer in silence one Sunday more. So, you may tell me now or I shall sit on this chair until you do.
And I warn you, I am very comfortable. Sarah looked at her empty hands for a long time. He did not ask me properly, she said at last. Not properly? Sarah, he went to your father first.