“For months,” he said, “every time my temper got the better of me, you asked me the same thing. What is underneath it?” His thumbs moved slowly over her knuckles. “You have never once asked me what is underneath the rest.” She could hardly breathe. “The rest. Ask me.” For a moment, she could not make her voice work at all.

“What is underneath, Richard?” “You.” He said it simply, as if it were the plainest fact in the world. “Every time I dug down far enough, it was you. Under the anger, under the pride, under every foolish, cruel thing I ever said to you. I built those walls so high, Sarah, and do you know what I was keeping out? Not the world.

You. Because I could not bear to want something that much and not be allowed to keep it.” Her eyes filled. She did not try to stop them. “I am tired of walking you home,” he said, and his voice broke, and he let it. “I’m tired of saying good night at your gate and counting the hours until morning.

I don’t want you for an afternoon. I don’t want to borrow you from your father’s house and give you back at dusk. I want every morning you have left. I want to grow old being asked what is underneath and to have the answer standing right in front of me.” He bent his head until his brow almost touched hers. So, I am not going to ask if you will have me, he said.

I am asking you to stay. The tears ran over then, all of them at once. She had wished for him to ask her. She had never once dreamed he would ask like this. All of them, she whispered, every morning.

Yes. He did not let go of her hands. He lifted them slowly and pressed his lips to her knuckles and held them there as if he were making a vow. Then, he turned her hands over and kissed each palm in turn, so gently that she felt it more in her heart than on her skin. And then, as though once could never be enough, he bowed his head and kissed her hands again.

These were the hands that had reached for Mary Beth at the drawing room door. The hands that had met his temper and never once struck back. The hands he meant to hold for the rest of his life. Sarah could not see him anymore for tears. She did not need to.

The winter sun went down over the lake, gilding the ice and the snow at their feet. Neither of them moved. He had spent his whole life building walls. And there, by the water, with her hands held to his lips, the last of them came down.

I was a real running fast.
Never stopped to see what I passed.
Took every bend You will prevent prevent my horse from drinking from my own river.
Sure, I was going somewhere.


I only want what was old.
Name a house and made it show.
I had them married all the same.
Never learned to say your name and you fell across my way.
Made me stay.
You were You were in my river.
You made the water slow.
You stood in the rush of my running till I had nowhere to go.
I never knew what I wanted till I couldn’t get past you.
Now the current’s quiet and all that I want is you.
You were uneasy.
You were my You were behaving held your ground as if the apology were owed to you.
You had your edges, I had mine.
Like stone in water over time.
But every word that cut me deep woke a man who’d been asleep.


I’d lived a life I’d never known.
Rushing on and all alone I was so blind.
I wish I’d seen how far we could have been.
You were the log in my river.
You made the water slow.
You stood in the rush of my running till I had nowhere to go.
I never knew what I wanted till I couldn’t get past you.
Now the current is quiet and all that I want is you.
If you had never stood there I’d still be rushing by, married maybe to a stranger never asking why.
So ask me what’s beneath the water.
Ask me what was always true underneath the rushing river.
It was you.
It was always you.
You were the log in my river.
You made the waters flow.
Now, I don’t want to be going anywhere you don’t go.
I never knew what I wanted till I couldn’t get past you.
Now, the river is still.
And all that I want is you.
Slow river, slow.
Let her hold you still.
Slow river, slow.