About three weeks before the night of the green dress, Gemma stopped by my shop on her lunch break, something she had never done before. She placed a single brass key on the counter. She said the winery was renting a new event space and her manager needed a duplicate before Friday.

I cut it in two minutes, but something caught my attention while I was working. It was a commercial key blank you could not buy in a hardware store. Only a handful of buildings in town used that system, and my shop serviced most of them. This key had a tiny stamp on its head: a building code.

I recorded the duplication in my logbook, the same way I recorded every key I made, and did not give it much more thought. I handed her the original and the copy. She kissed my cheek and left.

But I remember thinking that it was not a key to an event space. It was somebody’s apartment key. Remember that key. It comes back.

So there we were that Friday, a little after seven in the evening. I was at the kitchen table oiling a lock I had brought home from a job when I heard her heels on the stairs. Gemma did not wear heels to wine night. Gemma wore socks to wine night.

She came around the corner in a deep emerald-green dress, clearly tailored to fit her, and wearing the earrings I had bought her for our anniversary.

“Oh,” I said. “Where are you going?”

“Wine night at Ivy’s,” she said.

“In that outfit?”

She laughed, but it was a tight little laugh. I asked one more question, just one.

“Who is all this for, Gem?”

That was when her expression changed. She set her handbag down very slowly, like somebody preparing to deliver a speech she had rehearsed in the car.

“I’ll wear what I want tonight, Holden, or I’ll find a man who lets me.”

I know what you are thinking. You are thinking I should have gotten angry, snatched her keys, demanded a name, and maybe a younger version of me would have done exactly that. But when you have spent fifteen years standing in other people’s doorways on the worst days of their lives, you learn something. The person who raises their voice first is usually the one with something to hide.

So I stood up from the table, walked past her, opened the front door, and held it.

“Have a good night, Gemma.”

She stood still for a second as if the floor had shifted. She had come downstairs ready for a fight, and I had not given her one. Then she picked up her purse.