He even used the phrase, “My client felt unable to make choices about her own body.”
Harriet let him finish. Then she opened her briefcase and began placing things on the table, one by one, without much explanation.
The message from Ivy, timestamped 9:52. The pink alterations receipt made out to L. Castellano. The photograph of the robe hanging on the bathroom door. The photograph of the champagne. The bank transfer showing $18,000 moving from our joint account to Castellano Ridge.
And finally, a page from my shop’s own logbook. Date, time, building code, and customer name: Gemma Pryor. Paid in cash.
Her lawyer stopped talking.
“That doesn’t prove anything,” Gemma said very quietly.
“No, Mrs. Pryor,” Harriet answered. “But this might.”
The door opened, and Ivy walked in.
I had not told Gemma that Ivy would be there. In fact, I had not told her much of anything in eight days. Ivy sat down at the end of the table, placed her own folder in front of her, and looked directly at the woman who had been her best friend since college.
“I’m not signing on Thursday, Gem, in case you were wondering.”
Gemma just stared at her.
Then Ivy said something I had not expected.
“Landon came home Friday night after his key stopped working. He cried for an hour, and then he told me everything. He says it was your idea. The condo, the holding company, the roof money. He says you pushed him into it. He says he was going to break things off with you after the transfer went through.”
I watched the disappointment come across Gemma’s face. Whatever she had thought she had with Landon, however carefully she had dressed up, whatever kind of man she imagined would let her do as she pleased, he had betrayed her within an hour. He had not even waited until morning.
Gemma’s lawyer asked for a break. They never came back to the table.
The divorce took four months. Harriet had been right about everything. The cottage stayed mine. The court credited the $18,000 back to my side of the settlement, and the amount turned out to be almost exactly what the new roof cost.
Gemma moved in with her mother out in the valley. Her mother called me once to apologize for believing her.
“I raised her better than that, Holden,” she said.
“I know you did,” I told her.
Ivy filed for divorce on the Monday after our meeting. Because the condo had never been transferred into Landon’s name, he left with exactly what he had arrived with: a quarter-zip sweater and a useless key. The last I heard, he was living in his brother’s basement in Coeur d’Alene and selling used boats.
The winery found out Gemma had been meeting Landon in its event space after hours and fired her before Thanksgiving.
A month later, Ivy sold her father’s condo and bought a small house near the hospital. On the day the sale closed, she called me.
“I’ve got a new front door, and I don’t trust anybody else to key it for me.”
So I drove over and changed the locks. She made me coffee. Her father’s old mug was still on the counter.
“He would have wanted you to have the first cup,” she said.
I still think about that night sometimes. My wife told me she would wear whatever she wanted or find a man who would let her. And she did find one. He let her put our roof money into his scheme. He let her take the blame before the sun came up. He let the door lock behind her.
As for me, I never stopped her from doing a thing. I just held the door open and let her walk through.