“You’re being weird,” she said, and left.

I went back to the lock because my hands needed something to do.

At 9:52, my phone buzzed. It was Ivy.

“Hey, is Gemma feeling better? She canceled on me this afternoon. Said you had food poisoning. Hope you’re okay.”

I read it three times. Then I wrote back.

“I’m fine, Ivy. I’ve been fine all day. Can I call you?”

She called before I could put the phone down. And this is where things got worse.

While Ivy was talking, telling me that Gemma had been canceling on her for weeks, I walked over to the recycling bin by our back door. Right on top, beneath a flattened cereal box, was a pink receipt from Mrs. Lindquist’s alterations shop on Monroe Street. I knew Mrs. Lindquist. I had replaced the lock on her storefront after a break-in two years earlier.

The receipt was for one emerald evening gown, alterations to the waist and hem, $210, paid in full. And on the line marked “Paid by,” in Mrs. Lindquist’s careful old-fashioned handwriting, was a name: L. Castellano.

Ivy’s last name was Castellano.

I stood in my kitchen with Ivy’s voice in one ear and that pink slip of paper in my hand. I had about five seconds to decide whether I was going to destroy the life of the one person in this story who had done nothing wrong.

“Ivy, I need to read you something, and I need you to sit down.”

I read her the receipt. The line went so quiet that I thought we had been disconnected. Then she spoke in a small, level voice.

“He told me he had a client dinner tonight.”

And that was when I remembered the key.

“Ivy, does Landon have a private office somewhere? Not his company office?”

“He’s been using my father’s old condo. Apartment 704 at the Marlo on Riverside. Dad left it to me when he died. Landon said he needed somewhere quiet to work, so I gave him a key in March.”

The Marlo was one of the buildings that used that particular lock system. The building code stamped on the key my wife had brought to my counter matched it. She had not asked me to copy a key for an event space. She had asked me to make a duplicate for her boyfriend’s hiding place. I had done it in two minutes and wished her a good day.

“Ivy, whose name is on the deed to that condo?”

“Mine. Only mine. Landon has never been on it.”

“Then you get to decide who has a key.”

Ivy picked me up at 10:40 in her car, still wearing her nurse’s scrubs after a twelve-hour shift. When we reached the Marlo, she used her access card to enter the lobby, and we took the elevator to the seventh floor. She opened apartment 704 with her own original key, the one her father had given her. We stood in the doorway for a long moment.