Eleven days after the party, he put her belongings out in the hallway. Danny was the one who told me.
Brooke ended up sleeping on her sister’s couch two cities away. She’d given up her own apartment to move in with me, and now she had nowhere else to go. Her credit card, the one I’d told her to pay down with the rent money she was saving, apparently had a higher balance than it had on the day she moved in.
I heard all of that secondhand. I didn’t go looking for it.
And I didn’t answer a single one of the messages she sent me during that time. There were plenty. Apologies at midnight. Anger at three in the morning.
“You ruined my life over a joke.”
“You’re the only person who has ever really taken care of me.”
“I’m sorry. I’m sorry. I’m so sorry.”
Then nothing for a week.
A month after the party, she came to my door.
I knew it was her before I looked through the peephole. She always knocked twice quickly and then once slowly. I stood in my hallway for a second before opening it.
She looked different. Smaller somehow, with no makeup, her hair pulled back, and a sweatshirt I didn’t recognize. Her eyes went immediately to the new lock. I’d had it changed that Sunday morning, and something passed across her face when she noticed it.
She asked if she could come inside.
“We can talk here,” I told her.
She nodded, as though she’d expected that. Then she started speaking, and everything came out at once.
She said Jade had gotten into her head. She said she’d felt invisible, as if I’d stopped trying, as if I’d grown so comfortable with her that I’d forgotten she was there. She said she only needed to know I’d fight for her. She told me she was in therapy now and had cut ties with Jade and Tessa. She said she’d been stupid and cruel, and she knew it.
Then she said the thing she’d clearly come to say.
“I just wanted to know if you saw a future with me. I just wanted a ring, Ethan. That’s all I’ve ever wanted. Was that really so crazy?”
I didn’t answer. I held up a finger, asked her to wait, and went back to my bedroom.
I opened the top drawer of my dresser and took out the little velvet box. Then I returned to the door and opened it in front of her.
She stopped breathing. I mean that almost literally. Her chest went still. Her eyes moved from the ring to my face and back again, and she covered her mouth with one hand.
“It belonged to my grandmother,” I said. “She wore it for fifty-one years. I picked it up from the jeweler at two o’clock that Saturday afternoon, the same afternoon you accidentally sent me that voice message. You called to ask whether I’d received something strange. I told you no.”