Danny stared at me.

“Are you okay?”

“I’m doing better than I have in months. Trust me.”

He studied me for a long moment, then nodded slowly.

“Whatever you need, man.”

That’s Danny.

I spent the next hour being the nicest guy at the party. I talked to Leah’s father about his boat, refilled bowls of chips, and laughed at people’s jokes. Every so often, I caught one of the women watching me. Jade smiled at me from the island. Tessa kept checking her phone battery. Brooke met my eyes from across the room and gave me that small, sweet smile you might give someone just before pushing him off a ledge.

Around 9:30 p.m., someone else arrived, and everything clicked into place.

I didn’t recognize him right away. He was tall and bearded, wearing a nice jacket, and standing just inside the French doors with a beer, looking as though he was waiting for a bus. Then Brooke walked past and touched his arm. It wasn’t a hug, just a quick touch at the elbow, the sort of gesture you make with someone who shares a secret.

I leaned toward Danny and asked who he was. Danny frowned and said he thought the guy was a friend of Jade’s. She’d asked if she could bring someone.

But I knew that face. I’d seen it in old photos Brooke had shown me when she was telling me what a nightmare the man had been.

Cole.

He wasn’t waiting somewhere else. He was already there, in the front row.

The plan wasn’t just a test. It was a test with a safety net. If I begged, Brooke would get her Christmas ring and a viral video. If I didn’t, the next man was standing about ten feet away with a beer, ready to take her home. Either way, Brooke would win. That was the calculation, at least in her head.

About ten minutes later, Cole wandered toward the cooler where I was standing. He took out a beer, opened it, and looked me up and down like a man inspecting a used car he’d already decided to buy.

“You’re Brooke’s guy, aren’t you?” he asked.

“That’s what I hear.”

He smiled into his beer.

“She talks about you a lot. Says you’re really reliable.”

He said “reliable” the way most people say “boring.”

I could have said a hundred things. I could have told him I knew exactly who he was, that I’d seen his text on Brooke’s phone two hours earlier, and that I knew what he was waiting for. Instead, I tapped my bottle against his.

“Enjoy the party, man. It’s going to be a good one.”

He laughed as if I’d said something amusing. He had no idea he’d been cast in a story whose ending he hadn’t read.

Just before ten, Jade caught Brooke’s eye and tapped her wrist, signaling that it was time. Brooke took a deep breath and checked her hair in the reflection of the patio door. Tessa raised her phone. Jade raised hers. Brooke picked up a utensil from the snack table and tapped it against her glass.