So she played her last card. Her voice broke.
“You know what? If you really loved me, you would have proposed already. Two years, Ethan. Two years, and nothing.”
I felt the ring box against my ribs. My hand started to tremble toward my jacket, but I didn’t move it.
“The key, Brooke.”
She stared at me. Then, very slowly, with every eye in the house on her, she reached into her small purse. She took out her key ring and began removing my apartment key.
It took a while. Her hands were shaking, and the ring was one of those tight metal loops that fight you when you try to pull a key free. My key had a pink rubber cover she’d put on it so she could find it in the dark. Nobody spoke while she struggled. I could hear the ice shifting in people’s drinks.
When she finally got it loose, she dropped it into my palm. I closed my fingers around it.
“Thank you.”
Then I turned toward the fireplace, looked straight into Tessa’s phone, and said, “I hope you got all that. Ten o’clock sharp, right, Jade?”
Tessa dropped her phone onto the mantelpiece as if it had burned her. Jade went completely pale. I watched understanding spread through the room in a slow ripple.
Ten o’clock sharp? How could I have known the time? Why had Brooke’s friends been filming? Leah’s cousin, who was standing near me, whispered, “Oh my God. This was planned.”
Someone else asked, “Are they filming this for TikTok?”
Brooke opened her mouth. I didn’t wait to hear what she had to say. I walked over to Danny and Leah, apologized for the interruption, thanked them for inviting me, told Leah the house was beautiful, and went out the front door into the cold.
I was about halfway down the driveway when I heard the door open behind me. I thought it was Brooke. It was Danny.
He hurried toward me.
“What the hell was that?”
I told him everything: the voice message, the fact that Brooke had unsent it, her plan, and the ring. When I took out the little velvet box and opened it beneath the streetlamp, Danny stared at it and said a word I’m not going to repeat.
Then he asked, “Was she seriously going to make you beg for that?”
“She was going to make me beg for something I already had in my pocket.”
We were still near the end of his driveway when a black pickup truck pulled up across the street, its engine running and headlights on. About forty seconds later, Danny’s front door opened again. Brooke hurried out, mascara smeared across her face, with Cole right behind her, carrying his jacket.
She didn’t see us at first. She went straight toward the pickup, then spotted me standing beside Danny and froze with her hand on the passenger door.
I didn’t say anything. I didn’t have to. I simply raised the hand holding her key, its pink rubber cover catching the light, and gave her a little nod.