“Would it have mattered?” said Vivian.

She had not moved from the wall. She did not need to. Her voice was entirely level, and it carried the same distance Arthur’s had.

“You did not ask my name before you shoved me. You looked at me and decided in an instant that I was someone it was perfectly safe to push. That is what I should like you to consider, my lord. Not that you were wrong about who I was, but why you believed for even one moment that it would be acceptable at all.”

Fenn opened his mouth.

“You may leave,” said Arthur. “Now, please, and with whatever dignity you can manage.”

Fenn left. He held his chin up doing it. That was the part that stayed with Vivian through the rest of the evening and into the next morning. Not the shove itself, which had not truly hurt her, not the ruined gown, which could be replaced.

But the chin held up on the way out. The posture of a man who believed, underneath the embarrassment, that he had simply been unlucky. That he had pushed the wrong woman. Not that pushing was wrong.

By the following afternoon, the story had spread through three county drawing rooms and at least a dozen London parlors. Vivian was beginning to hear a pattern in the responses and it was not a comfortable one.

“Oh, Fenn has always been like that,” said Lady Grosmont, Arthur’s nearest neighbor and a woman who had known the Hartwell family for 30 years.

She said it at tea the next day with the easy calm of someone describing the local weather.

“A frightful temper with anyone he considers beneath him. One learns to keep one’s own people well out of his path. There is a whole art to it, really, when he attends anything.”

“You knew,” said Vivian, “that he does this?”

Lady Grosmont looked faintly surprised by the directness of the observation.

“My dear, it is rather widely known, but he endows the Society for Parish Roads quite generously and the county magistrates would fall apart without his organizational hand. What precisely does one do with a man like that?”

Vivian set her cup down with a care that her hands did not entirely feel.

“One could start,” she said, “by believing the people he does it to.”

Lady Grosmont looked at her the way a person looks at someone who has just suggested something structurally impossible, like rerouting a river.


PART 2 — The Courage to Ask Whose Voice Counts – “Stupid Girl,” He Snapped, and Shoved the Duke’s Wife Into the Wall — He Had No Idea Whose House He Was In

PART 2 — The Courage to Ask Whose Voice Counts – “Stupid Girl,” He Snapped, and Shoved the Duke’s Wife Into the Wall — He Had No Idea Whose House He Was In