He did not raise his voice. He did not need to. The room went silent. Crane smiled.

“Of course, Your Grace.”

Simon stood up. He took a book from under his arm and laid it on the table. Then he laid a second book beside it.

“This,” he said, touching the first, “is the book of accounts that Mr. Crane sends to my agent every quarter. It says the mill has lost money for 3 years.”

He touched the second.

“This is a book that Miss Louisa Keating kept by her own hand every day for those same three years. She counted every cart of wool from her window. She wrote down every bale of cloth that went out. And it says the mill has made more money than ever before.”

Crane’s smile went thin.

“Your Grace, that book was stolen from my office.”

“Was it?” said Simon. “You told Mr. Keating it was Miss Keating’s private book. How did it come to be locked in your cupboard?”

Crane said nothing. Somebody in the back of the room laughed and then stopped.

“Mr. Allerton,” said Simon, “would you stand up?”

An old man with white whiskers stood up near the window. He was the clerk from the town bank.

“Mr. Allerton, has Mr. Crane an account at your bank?”

“No, Your Grace. He has one in Liverpool. We send money to it each month on his order from the mill’s account. I told Miss Louisa so a year ago. She was the only one who ever asked.”

The murmur in the room grew louder.

“One more thing,” said Simon.

He picked up one of Crane’s receipts and held it to the window light.

“This receipt is dated last March. Mr. Allerton, you are a stationer as well as a clerk. Whose paper is this?”

The old man came and looked. He held it to the light, too, and he frowned.

“That is Hartley paper, Your Grace, from the new mill at Bolton. You can see the mark there, a little crown. That mill did not open until July.”

He looked up.

“This paper did not exist last March. Nobody could have written on it.”

The room broke into noise. Men stood up. Someone called out, “Shame!” Hugh Keating had gone white to the lips. Crane looked around him very fast. For the first time he did not look neat at all.